The LDA þ U approach can be used essentially as a shift potential to open up the band gap of a semiconductor. This approach was previously applied to the oxygen vacancy in ZnO by Paudel and Lambrecht (PL) [Phys. Rev. B 77, 205202 (2008)]. Here, we review the results of that approach and introduce additional refinements of the LDA þ U model. Good agreement is obtained with recent hybrid functional calculations on the position of the "ð2 þ =0Þ transition state. A comparison of various approaches on the oxygen vacancy in ZnO is provided. The relevance of the one-electron levels to the experiments is discussed. 1 Introduction The local density approximation (LDA) is well known to underestimate band gaps in semiconductors. In a recent paper, Paudel and Lambrecht [1] (PL), discussed this problem for the oxygen vacancy V O in ZnO. The problem appears to be rather dramatic in this case as different authors do not even agree on whether the relevant defect level, the 2þ/0 transition level lies in the upper or the lower half of the band gap. Discrepancies also exist between different authors on the magnitude of the energy of formation of the defect and on the positions of the one-electron levels. At the time that paper was written, previous work had addressed the gap corrections mostly in a posteriori fashion [2][3][4][5][6][7]. The point of the PL paper was to use an adjusted Hamiltonian and total energy functional that gave the correct band gap for the host and then apply it to the defect transition levels. In particular, they used the LDA þ U approach with U Coulomb interactions not only for the d states of Zn but also the s orbitals. The idea behind this unorthodox application of LDA þ U is explained below. Since that work and even before, the problem has been investigated by several others by a variety of approaches, hybrid functionals [8][9][10], the GW method [9], and screened exchange [11,12]. Here, we critically re-examine the results of PL and explore the LDA þ U model further with additional U i parameters, which overcome some of the shortcomings of the previous U d þ U s
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.