REVIEWS notions held by Bach and his contemporaries and many hitherto puzzling obscurities in the cantata texts are clarified. It is interesting to see, for example, how the editors of the nineteenth-century Bach-Gesdbchaft edition of the cantatas, working at a period when typology as a system of biblical interpretation was largely forgotten, were persuaded to make alterations in texts which they found incomprehensible. Thus, in Cantata No. 52, Falsche Welt, dir trau ich nicht, published in 1862 in volume 12 of the Gesamtausga.be der Bachgesellschaft, we find that the word 'Armer' was substituted for the original word 'Abner' in the line 'Wenn Joab kiisst, so muss einfrommer Armer sterben'. As Helene Werthemann points out, Joab and Abner are, of course, referred to in this context as the types of Judas and Christ respectively. At the present time, when performances of Bach's cantatas are limited almost entirely to the concert hall or to the broadcasting and recording studio, there is an inevitable tendency to lose sight of the liturgical and theological significance of the texts on which they are based. Books, such as the one under review, written with scholarship and clarity of style, may well prove a useful corrective. A small printing error occurs in the quotation in the footnote on p. 107: 'Romantik' should read 'Romanik'.
whether the doctrine of sovereignty really has ceded ground to the extent suggested. And il it really is an English rather than a Scottish doctrine, it has certainly been held by many Scots with a quite destructive tenacity. Furthermore, Professor Lyall says nothing of the possible effects of this doctrine within the Church, causing General Assemblies to regard Presbyteries as mere creatures of their own. The House of Lprds decision of 1904, in which the small body of continuing Free Churchmen won the whole property of the Free Church before the majority joined in forming the United Free Church, is one which Professor Lyall suggests 'was both right and legally correct'. This view will horrify most Scots, but his conclusion is solidly based on Scottish precedents in law and cannot be lightly dismissed. And on the extent to which civil courts will now intervene in church affairs, he quotes the 1940 case of five nuns who refused to leave their convent, it being then held that the courts may act when the ecclesiastical authorities have moved outside their own jurisdiction or have behaved with such gross irregularity 'as shall amount to the entire breaking up of the contract'. The book is more readable than the subject might lead one to expect; and the use ol one set ol footnotes with numbers running throughout is helpful. Yet if this book is mainly intended* for Scottish readers, it ought not be neglected in what is playfully called 'the established church in South Britain'. The Church of Scotland may have suffered from monolithic theories of the state to a greater degree than the Church of England, but neither went unscathed, and it is the Church of England which still has furthest to go in extricating itself from the parliamentary embrace.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.