Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte der aDNA-Forschung

Abstract

From a Historical Perspective aDNA studies are a cooperative field of research with a broad range of applications including evolutionary biology, genetics, anthropology and archaeology. Scientists are using ancient molecules as source material for historical questions. Colleagues from the humanities are observing this with both interest and concern because aDNA research is affecting academic identities and both concepts of history and historiography. aDNA research developed in a way that can be described as a Hype Cycle (Chackie Fenn). Technological triggers such as Sanger Sequencing and the Polymerase Chain Reaction kicked off a multitude of experiments with ancient DNA during the 1980s and 1990s. Geneticists, microbiologists, anthropologists and many more euphorically joined a "molecule hunt". aDNA was promoted as a time machine. Media attention was enormous. As experiments and implementations began to fail and contamination was discovered to be a tremendous problem, media interest waned and many labs lost their interest. Some turned their disillusionment into systematic research into methodology and painstakingly established lab routines. The authenticity problem was first addressed by control oriented measures but later approached from a more cognitive theoretical perspective as the pitfalls and limits of aDNA became clearer. By the end of the 2000s the field reached its current plateau of productivity. Cross-disciplinary debates, conflicts and collaborations are increasing critical reflection among all participants. Historians should consider joining the field in a kind of critical friendship to both make the most of its possibilities and give an input from a constructivist perspective.

Ancient genetics to ancient genomics: celebrity and credibility in data-driven practice

“…Elsbeth Bösl has also written on the history of ancient DNA research via a recently published article, "Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte der aDNA-Forschung" (March 2017), and a recently published book, Doing Ancient DNA: Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte Der Adna-Forschung (August 2017), in German. See Bösl (2017a) and (2017b). scientific, epistemic, and generational views regarding the proper practice of ancient DNA research.…”

Über mediale Präsenz und Prominenz DNA-gestützter Vergangenheitsforschung

“…Es hat in den letzten Jahren durch zahlreiche beachtenswerte Veröffentlichungen viel -auch mediale -Aufmerksamkeit erzeugt und erfahren. Es gibt mittlerweile erste wissenschaftshistorische Untersuchungen (Bösl 2017), Sammelbände (z. B. Brather-Walther 2019, mehrere Special Issues und Themenhefte in einschlägigen Zeitschriften (etwa Medieval Worlds 2016;NAR 2017 und das Forum in dieser Zeitschrift) sowie populärwissenschaftliche Bücher von zentralen Protagonisten (Reich 2018;Krause 2019), die das Forschungsfeld mal anhand eines konkreten Problems, mal als Ganzes diskutieren und dabei Debatten innerhalb der beteiligten Fächer abbilden und anstoßen (zu einem aktuellen Überblick: Bösl & Feuchter 2019).…”