Youth substance use service provider’s perspectives on use and service access in ontario: time to reframe the discourse

Abstract

Background Age is a critical factor in substance use and related outcomes, with adolescence being a particularly sensitive period. Early initiation of substance use has been linked with higher risk for developing substance use disorders. In Ontario, Canada, substance use is common among youth, yet treatment is underutilized, suggesting the potential for an unmet need in terms of substance use care. Despite these challenges, there is limited research examining factors that contribute to youth substance use and youth-specific barriers to substance use care. To fill this knowledge gap, this study sought to include the unique perspectives of service providers who work directly with youth to examine these issues. Methods We used a cross-sectional mixed-methods design to examine factors that contribute to substance use among youth and identify youth-specific barriers to substance use among a sample of 54 Ontario-based youth service providers. Data collection included an online survey completed by all study participants followed by qualitative interviews of a subsample of 16 participants. Data analysis included basic frequency tabulations for survey results and thematic qualitative analyses to identify common themes. Results Licit substances were identified as the most commonly used among youth, where 94% of respondents identified cannabis use and 81% identified alcohol use. Thematic analyses identified the role of dominant substance use discourses in normalizing certain substances (i.e., cannabis and alcohol) while also endorsing stigmatizing beliefs and sentiments. According to youth service providers, the intersection of these two discourses simultaneously lead to an increase in substance use while deterring youth from seeking substance use care. Conclusions Normalization and stigmatization are two dominant discourses around youth substance use, with important implications for public health interventions. Key public health strategies, as identified by participants, to reduce the overall negative effect of these factors include the need to reframe substance use discourse, from a moral failing to a public health issue and to educate youth about the impacts of use. To accomplish this goal educational campaigns to raise awareness around the health effects of use and address stigmatization are needed. Educational reforms are also needed to ensure that these programs are integrated into the school system.

Loneliness, affective disorders, suicidal ideation, and the use of psychoactive substances in a sample of adolescents during the COVID‐19 pandemic: A cross‐sectional study

“…Studies have shown that a difficult relationship with family members (Temple et al, 2022), a poor relationship with parents and a lack of parental monitoring and family support (Ali et al, 2022) are predictors of an increased use of illicit substances (alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs) among youths.…”

Experience of psychologists in the delivery of cognitive behaviour therapy in a non-western culture for treatment of substance abuse: a qualitative study

“…Although the level of education cannot be increased, attempts may be made at the start of the therapy to at least educate the person with substance abuse about the negative effects of substance abuse and effectiveness of CBT to counter them. An earlier qualitative study [ 27 ] showed that young adults who were not educated about the potential adverse effects of addictive substances were more inclined to abuse substances. Educational reforms were suggested in this study [ 27 ] for the awareness of youth about the risks of substance use for physical health and psychological well-being.…”

“…An earlier qualitative study [ 27 ] showed that young adults who were not educated about the potential adverse effects of addictive substances were more inclined to abuse substances. Educational reforms were suggested in this study [ 27 ] for the awareness of youth about the risks of substance use for physical health and psychological well-being.…”

Understanding Chinese international students’ perception of cultural conflicts in Canada: Through the case of cannabis use

“…This trend is also reflected in surveys conducted in Canadian universities, as a previous survey, with more than 23,000 Canadian university students, found that prior to legalization, students who self-reported using cannabis (i.e., from daily use to less than once a year) ranged from 23.4% to 56.4% in 49 universities across Canada (Brownell, 2018). Research has also found that the ongoing discourse regarding legalization of cannabis has led to the normalization of cannabis consumption, with increased numbers of youth experimenting with cannabis, despite cannabis remaining illegal for them (Ali et al, 2022).…”

“…These factors help drive a strong market demand for cannabis. Culturally, cannabis use has also been normalized in Canada (Ali et al, 2022). Some researchers suggested that cannabis attaches to the cultural hierarchy and reflects this ‘white’, ‘male’, and ‘middle-class’ dominant culture (Mabee, 2019; Schlussel, 2017).…”