‘You have to treat the person, not the mouth only’: UK dentists’ perceptions of communication in patient consultations

Abstract

Effective communication between patients and health professionals is a key component of patient-centred care. Although there is a large body of literature focusing on doctor-patient communication, there has been limited research related to dentist-patient communication, especially presented from the dentists' perspective. The aim of our study was to explore UK dentists' perceptions of communication in their consultations, and the factors they perceive may influence this. We conducted semi-structured interviews with eight dentists in UK dental NHS practices. Thematic analysis revealed three themes ('Treating the whole person', 'Barriers to patient-centred communication' and 'Mutuality of communication'), which reflected the dentists' perceptions of their own communication during consultations, the patients' interaction skills, attitudes (and characteristics that may affect them), and external factors, such as time constraints, that can influence dentist-patients' encounters. These in-depth accounts are valuable, in that we see what dentists perceive is important, obstructive and facilitative. They report using a patient-centred approach in their everyday dental practice; however this is often difficult due to factors such as time constraints. Although they emphasized that the patient has an active role to play in the communication process, it may be the case that they also need to play their part in facilitating this.

What influences the provision and reception of oral health education? A narrative review of the literature

“…Richards 22 recommended dental professionals adopt a wider definition of success than one solely focused on individual cases. Training in working with patients from different backgrounds and helping them to appreciate the means and contexts which influence patients' behaviours was also recommended to help dental professionals have more realistic expectations of patients' scope for change 95 …”

Dental hygienists’ use of motivational interviewing and perceptions of effectiveness in changing patient behaviors

“…Nowak et al. had similar findings as dentists reported, “there was only so much they could do if patients don't follow their recommendations.” 32 Behavior change is complex and the literature across health disciplines points to a limited understanding of how health professionals and their patients can achieve optimal behavior change 15 . A lack of positive behavior change is evident within MI literature, as many studies reported seeing no change in behavioral or clinical outcomes as a result of MI interventions 19,25–27 .…”

Patient satisfaction with dental treatment at a university dental clinic: A qualitative analysis

“…Effective communication affects not only patient satisfaction, but clinical outcomes as well 28 . If communication is fundamental in providing high quality dental care, then integration of these concepts into the dental curriculum is essential, focusing not only on a dentist's responsibility for the flow of communication, but also on the patient's interaction and mutuality of the process 29 . Our study has found that communication about cost, the steps of the procedure planned to be performed, the treatment plan, scheduling, the change in providers, any delays, and the way the College of Dentistry works impact patient satisfaction.…”