You can't always get what you want: How entrepreneur's perceived resource needs affect the incubator's assertiveness

Abstract

A possible explanation for the disappointing performance of incubators is that start-ups do not take full advantage of the resources offered by the incubator. In explaining the low usage of the incubator's resources, existing studies neglect that incubated entrepreneurs may not be aware of the gaps in their resource base. Using qualitative data from six European incubators, we identify start-ups' resource needs as perceived by incubator staff and by entrepreneurs. Further, we explore the implications of differences in perceptions for the incubator's assertiveness. We find that entrepreneurs are unable to use the incubator's resources to develop missing intangible resources: entrepreneurs are not aware of their resource gaps, hesitant to step out of their comfort zone, and primarily short-term oriented. In order to ensure that start-ups develop a comprehensive resource base, incubators supporting early stage startups were found to take an assertive strategy, creating self-awareness among entrepreneurs, and encouraging them to make use of the incubator's resources. Our study adds to current incubator literature by providing a more comprehensive explanation for the low usage of the incubator's resources, by identifying circumstances under which an assertive strategy is desirable and by exploring the practices through which an assertive strategy can be implemented.

Factors to Support a New Tech Start-up for Business Incubation

“…For young tech start-ups in the bootstrapping stage the important support service is educating and setting the entrepreneurship mindset. We agreed with van Weel et al [17], who implies that the first step toward success in tech start-up is the business knowledge through coaching and training. Additionally, the networking become one of the success factors for tech start-ups in seed stage and creating stage, but not in bootstrapping stage.…”

Exploring the motives and practices of university–start-up interaction: evidence from Route 128

“…For startups, the ability to acquire and develop resources has shown to be crucial for survival (Dollinger 1999). In particular, knowledge about how do to business and access to social networks are considered important (Bruneel et al 2007;Eveleens et al 2017;Van Weele et al 2017).…”

“…The following list of resources is not exhaustive, but outlines the most important resources that universities and start-ups require for attaining their objectives. We base this categorization on Van Weele et al (2017), who used it to understand the resource needs of clean-tech start-ups at university incubators. Other studies have taken a similar approach (e.g.…”

“…Established firms have the resources and market power to make radical innovation successful (Chandy and Tellis 2000), but are often inhibited by their own existing routines (Becker 2004) and internal inertial forces (Hannan and Freeman 1984). UII is important as start-ups still need access to resources after venture creation, such as specialized equipment, knowledge, social capital, and legitimacy, which are crucial for firm survival (Van Weele et al 2017). Interacting with universities can provide access to these resources (Santoro and Chakrabarti 2002).…”

Network brokers or hit makers? Analyzing the influence of incubation on start-up investments

“…There is a broad variety of services that incubators can offer, depending on the goal of the incubator (Bergek and Norrman 2008;Schwartz and Hornych 2008), and conditions in the surrounding entrepreneurial ecosystem (Spigel 2015;Steinz et al 2015;Van Weele et al 2016b). Incubator services include, but are not limited to, shared equipment, seed capital, coaching, training to develop business skills, organization of networking events, access to professional service providers (e.g.…”