Classical high-fidelity DNA polymerases discriminate between the correct and incorrect nucleotides by using geometric constraints imposed by the tight fit of the active site with the incipient base pair. Consequently, Watson-Crick (W-C) hydrogen bonding between the bases is not required for the efficiency and accuracy of DNA synthesis by these polymerases. DNA polymerase (Pol) is a low-fidelity enzyme able to replicate through DNA lesions. Using difluorotoluene, a nonpolar isosteric analog of thymine unable to form W-C hydrogen bonds with adenine, we found that the efficiency and accuracy of nucleotide incorporation by Pol are severely impaired. From these observations, we suggest that W-C hydrogen bonding is required for DNA synthesis by Pol; in this regard, Pol differs strikingly from classical high-fidelity DNA polymerases.Classical DNA polymerases, such as T7 and Escherichia coli Klenow, synthesize DNA with high fidelity, and they are unable to replicate through DNA lesions (7). By contrast, the eukaryotic polymerase (Pol) is a low-fidelity enzyme (16,28,45) with the ability to replicate through DNA lesions. Pol is unique among eukaryotic DNA polymerases in its proficient ability to replicate through UV-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) (15). Remarkably, both yeast and human Pol insert A's opposite the two T's of a cis-syn thyminethymine (TT) dimer with the same efficiency and accuracy as they insert A's opposite undamaged template bases (16,44). In addition to TT dimers, UV light also induces the formation of CPDs at 5Ј-TC-3Ј and 5Ј-CC-3Ј sites, and genetic studies with Saccharomyces cerevisiae have indicated a role of Pol in the accurate bypass of these lesions as well (48). Because of its role in promoting the error-free bypass of CPDs, inactivation of Pol in humans causes UV hypermutability (43) and results in the cancer-prone syndrome, the variant form of xeroderma pigmentosum (14,27). Yeast Pol also replicates through an 8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) lesion efficiently and accurately, and genetic studies with S. cerevisiae have corroborated the requirement of Pol in the error-free bypass of this DNA lesion (11).From studies done with nonpolar isosteric analogs of natural DNA bases which lack the ability to form Watson-Crick (W-C) hydrogen (H) bonds, it has been concluded that W-C H bonding is not needed for DNA synthesis by classical high-fidelity DNA polymerases (30,32,33); rather, the geometric fit of the incoming nucleotide with the templating base within the polymerase active site is the principal determinant of the efficiency and fidelity of DNA synthesis in these polymerases (7,9,22). Here we examine the effects of difluorotoluene (F), which is virtually identical in shape, size, and conformation to thymine (T) but lacks the ability to form W-C H bonds with adenine (A) (Fig. 1A), on DNA synthesis by yeast Pol. Because of the inability of F to form W-C H bonds in water (37, 38), this compound is ideal for examining the relative importance of hydrogen bonds and steric effects on DNA synthesis. P...