“…Sm, 169 Eu, 171 Gd, 173 Tb, 174 Tb, 175 Dy, 176 Dy, 177 Ho, 178 Ho, 179 Er, 180 Er 104 Rb, 113 Zr, 116 Nb, Tc, 125 Ru, 128 Rh, 130 Pd, 131 Pd, 140 Sn, 142 Sb, 145 Te, 146 I, 147 I, 149 Xe, 150 Xe, 157 La Ca, 60 Ca, 62 Sc, 59 K 28 Cl, 30 Cl , La, 156,157,158 Ce, 156,157,158,159,160,161 Pr, 162,163 Nd, 164,165 Pm, 166,167 Sm, 169 Eu, 171 Gd, 173,174 Tb, 175,176 Dy, 177,178 Ho, and 179,180 Er." However, Fukuda et al is only credited with the discovery of the 15 isotopes listed inTable 1as the others had previously been reported by Wu 19. Unfortunately, Fukuda et al did neither acknowledge nor reference the earlier paper.In the paper "Observation of new neutron-rich isotopes among fission fragments from in-flight fission of 345 MeV/nucleon 238 U: Search for new isotopes conducted concurrently with decay measurement campaigns" Shimizu et al reported the discovery of 17 new nuclides 12.…”