“…The proton discharge reaction is fast and H 2 is evolved in a rate-determining combination reaction or Tafel step [48,49]. With regard to VC-NS, the Tafel slope is 56 mV dec À 1 , which is comparable to those of MoP, MoC x and CoP/Ti [44,46,50] but smaller than those of WS 2 , MoS 2 , Mo 2 N, MoSe 2 , and WSe 2 -C [40,45,51,52], listed in Table S2, indicating that HER occurs via a Volmer-Heyrovsky HER mechanism and electrochemical desorption is the rate-limiting step [48,49], The exchange current densities j 0 (defined as the current density at zero overpotential) of the electrocatalysts determined from the Tafel plots by extrapolation are listed in Table S1. VC-NS shows a j 0 value of 0.193 mA cm À 2 which is larger than that of VC-P of 0.092 mA cm À 2 .…”