Working with teams of "insiders"

Abstract

BACKGROUNDThe convergence of two qualitative methodological strategies -working in "teams" and with "insiders" -can facilitate access, efficiency, and insights into research questions of interest to demographers. Even though this approach is becoming more common among population researchers in the Global South to address a range of research questions, little has been published that describes the method and critically assesses its strengths and weaknesses. OBJECTIVEWe draw on three projects embedded in the Agincourt Health and Socio-Demographic Surveillance System site in rural South Africa that integrate both approaches to demonstrate the benefits and limitations of this strategy. METHODWe document, through in-depth description, how these three projects achieve access, efficiency, and insights into issues of population concern (HIV/AIDS, aging, and child wellbeing) utilizing a "team-insider" approach by working with groups of local research assistants. CONCLUSIONSThe projects vary in their use of "teams" and "insiders" but collectively deepen our understanding of pressing population concerns in the Global South. In particular, by using teams of insiders, these projects gain insights into local ideas about HIV, uncover ways that HIV affects older women"s lives, and provide in-depth understanding of children"s social connections. The approach also presents a number of challenges, however, such as grappling with the responsibilities and burdens that are placed on local insider team members.

Cultivating capacities in community-based researchers in low-resource settings: Lessons from a participatory study on violence and mental health in Sri Lanka

“…Empathy and personal growth. (Emotional) safety of researchers in sensitive studies is slowly gaining visibility [7], but seldom extends to CBRs [6,33]. As an embodied experience, participatory violence and mental health research requires emotional connectedness and bearing witness to myriad forms of trauma with implications for wellbeing [7,34,35].…”

“…Participatory methods, which rely heavily on community-based researchers (CBRs), are growing in popularity to deliver such critical research, bringing rewards and challenges for research teams and affected communities [2,3]. While research institutions, funders, and ethics bodies increasingly encourage practice standards to support wellbeing among participants in (participatory) violence and mental health studies [4,5], comparable efforts to understand and advocate for attending to the role-specific needs of researchers, and especially CBRs, are lacking [6,7]. Given the legacy of imbalanced power relations "in the creation of global health, and how [it] persists in the field" [8, p1059], concerted efforts to value the expertise and capacities of local collaborators like CBRs and communities are paramount in contemporary global health research [2].…”

Ethical challenges in participatory action research: Experiences and insights from an arts-based study in the pacific

“…Research teams that include insiders and outsiders can provide important advantages related to maximising trustworthiness of findings whilst supporting participant wellbeing (Schatz et al, 2015; Thomas et al, 2000). The different social positions of each member of the research team meant each could provide participants with different types of support.…”

Shifting towards community-building in opening up FabLabs for non-expert users

“…The concept of 'insiders' refers to the position of peers who are working within one's own cultural or social community (Vaughn et al, 2018). The caseanalysis showed that Abby was perceived by her peers as more approachable and reliable due to her insider status, knowledge and shared experiences and became the intermediary between FabLab team and her own community of youth (work) organizations (Guta et al, 2013;Schatz et al, 2015;Vaughn et al, 2018 However, this intermediary role works in two ways: Abby shares the perspective of the youth (work) organizations with the FabLab, but also shares the ideas and opportunities of the FabLab with her peers of the youth (work) organizations. For instance Abby stated that:…”