Working the night shift: a necessary time for training or a risk to health and safety?

Abstract

The European Working Time Directive (EWTD) limits excessive night shifts and restricts the working week to no more than 48 hours. The underlying rationale is to minimise the health risks to all workers. Here we debate the impact of night rotas for doctors-in-training on patient safety and medical education; when the EWTD was agreed these topics may not have been considered, either systematically or objectively. The impacts of diurnal rhythms on human functions affect all night workers, but the nature of rostered medical and surgical work has little precedent in other industries or even in the contracts of other healthcare staff. For example, rostered night duties need to be distinguished from permanent night shift work. On-call medical night work from training doctors is generally required for short periods and usually involves fewer patients. It is an important time in training, where clinical responsibility and decision-making can be matured in a supervised setting. To comply with the EWTD most hospitals have adopted rota patterns that aim to cover the clinical needs, while ensuring no doctor works for more than 48 hours in an average working week. To monitor this process longterm studies are necessary to evaluate effects on a doctor's health and on patient care generally. The EWTD has also led to a loss of continuity of patient care; does this really matter?

Association of Resident Duty Hour Restrictions, Level of Trainee, and Number of Available Residents with Mortality in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit

“…On call work contributes to develop autonomy and clinical judgment. 28 Despite reductions in resident training hours after the duty hour reform, we did not find deleterious effects in outcomes of infants admitted to the NICU. The duty hour reform was likely beneficial, as we found a decrease in the adjusted odds of early mortality.…”

The changing UK paediatric consultant workforce: report from the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health

“…This model was supported by the RCPCH14 and has been widely adopted by trusts employing paediatricians. Using that model and to meet RCPCH safety standards for acute general paediatric services,2 taking into account greater awareness of work–life balance among trainees and new consultants,15 recognising the risks of excessive hours16 and allowing for prospective cover of 20%, at least eight general paediatric consultants are required for a full rota. That calculation was based on a consultant being present and available 12 hours a day and 7 days per week at times of peak activity.…”

Should sleepy patients see general neurologists?

“…6 It can be associated with impaired alertness, impacting on quality of life and impairing performance with inevitable consequences for safety. 7,8 Although a number of potential causes exist for sleepiness, including most commonly, obstructive sleep apnoea hypopnoea syndrome (OSAHS), these are usually evident with an associated history of snoring or witnessed breathing pauses and are commonly referred to respiratory sleep units. When the diagnosis is less clear, referral to neurology may be made to consider non-respiratory causes.…”