Working hours of full-time hospital physicians in Japan: a cross-sectional nationwide survey

Abstract

Background The culture of excessively long overtime work in Japan has not been recently addressed. New legislation on working hours, including a limitation on maximum overtime work for physicians, will be enforced in 2024. This study was performed to elucidate the working conditions of full-time hospital physicians and discuss various policy implications. Methods A facility survey and a physician survey regarding physicians’ working conditions were conducted in July 2022. The facility survey was sent to all hospitals in Japan, and the physician survey was sent to all physicians working at half of the hospitals. The physicians were asked to report their working hours from 11 to 17 July 2022. In addition to descriptive statistics, a multivariate logistic regression analysis on the factors that lead to long working hours was conducted. Results In total, 11,466 full-time hospital physicians were included in the analysis. Full-time hospital physicians worked 50.1 h per week. They spent 45.6 h (90.9%) at the main hospital and 4.6 h (9.1%) performing side work. They spent 43.8 h (87.5%) on clinical work and 6.3 h (12.5%) on activities outside clinical work, such as research, teaching, and other activities. Neurosurgeons worked the longest hours, followed by surgeons and emergency medicine physicians. In total, 20.4% of physicians were estimated to exceed the annual overtime limit of 960 h, and 3.9% were estimated to exceed the limit of 1860 h. A total of 13.3% and 2.0% exceeded this level only at their primary hospital, after excluding hours performing side work. Logistic regression analysis showed that male, younger age, working at a university hospital, working in clinical areas of practice with long working hours, and undergoing specialty training were associated with long working hours after controlling for other factors. Conclusions With the approaching application of overtime regulations to physicians, a certain reduction in working hours has been observed. However, many physicians still work longer hours than the designated upper limit of overtime. Work reform must be further promoted by streamlining work and task-shifting while securing the functions of university hospitals such as research, education, and supporting healthcare in communities.

Implications for the specialty board system: The struggle of young doctors in Japan's rigid healthcare framework

“…5 Japan's postgraduate training system, particularly after the 2018 reforms, imposes stringent restrictions on young physicians' mobility by mandating participation in programs approved by the Japan Medical Specialty Board, which system effectively prevents physicians from transferring to other hospitals without withdrawing from their programs, which contributed to the resident's inability to seek relief from his overwhelming workload. 6,7 The monopolistic nature of this system is further illustrated by the enrolment figures in the fiscal year 2023, where 9325 physicians were registered in these programs, closely aligning with the 9058 successful candidates of the 2021 medical licencing examination.…”