Work stress associated cool down reactions among nurses and hospital physicians and their relation to burnout symptoms

Abstract

BackgroundHospital staff experience high level of work stress and they have to find strategies to adapt and react to it. When they perceive emotional exhaustion and job dissatisfaction in response to constant work stress, one reaction might be emotional withdrawal. This emotional distancing can be seen as an adaptive strategy to keep ‘functionality’ in the job. Both, perception of emotional exhaustion and emotional distancing as a strategy, can be operationalized as ‘Cool Down’. We assume that work stress associated variables are positively associated with Cool Down reactions, while internal and external resources are negatively associated and might function as a buffer against emotional distancing. Moreover, we assume that the perception of stress and work burden might be different between nurses and physicians and women and men, but not their cool down reactions as a strategy.MethodsAnonymous cross-sectional survey with standardized instruments among 1384 health care professionals (66% nurses, 34% hospital physicians). Analyses of variance, correlation and also stepwise regression analyses were performed to analyze the influence of demands and resources on Cool Down reactions.ResultsAs measured with the Cool Down Index (CDI), frequency and strength of Cool Down reactions did not significantly differ between women and men, while women and men differ significantly for their burnout symptoms, stress perception and perceived work burden. With respect to profession, Cool Down and stress perception were not significantly different, but burnout and work burden. For nurses, “Emotional Exhaustion” was the best CDI predictor (51% explained variance), while in physicians it was “Depersonalization” (44% explained variance). Among putative resources which might buffer against Cool Down reactions, only team satisfaction and situational awareness had some influence, but not self-efficacy expectation.ConclusionThe perceptions of emotional exhaustion and distancing of nurses and physicians (and women and men) seems to be different, but not their adaptive Cool Down reactions. Data would support the notion that a structural approach of support would require first to control and eliminate work stressors, and second a multifaceted approach to strengthen and support hospital staff’s resources and resilience.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12913-017-2445-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Development in Danish medical students’ empathy: study protocol of a cross-sectional and longitudinal mixed-methods study

“…However, as future physicians, they are confronted with increasing work stress and contact with suffering patients which may result in burnout indicators such as emotional exhaustion and emotional withdrawal. For that reason, future physicians must find strategies to protect their own functionality [17]. One of the major tasks in medical education is to maintain or increase clinical empathy among medical students and to help them find and train strategies to cope with these future stressors that might also decrease their motivation in the clinical routine.…”

The Impact of Understaffing on Delaying Early-Stage SARS-CoV-2 Outbreak Detection

“…Prolonged exposure to stress often directly harms workers and indirectly impacts the outcomes. Explained excessive workload as "burnout" or a managerial inability to deal with tasks [55,56,57]. This has severe repercussions especially in the medical field, where an error can cause the death of thousands or over people.…”

Talent Management Predictors that Adversely Affect Job Satisfaction at a South African Parastatal

“…Job dissatisfaction can also emanate from the absence of promotional opportunities and good leadership (Ongunlana, Oshinaike & Ibrahim, 2016;Munyengabe et al, 2017). Perceptions of stress differ among employees and these were conceptualized as antecedents of job dissatisfaction (Rossler, 2012;Bussing et al, 2017). Similarly, the perceptions of downsizing organizations proved to cause dissatisfaction in younger employees and also among those who survived downsizing in general (Lahner et al, 2014).…”