Work-related factors predict changes in physical activity among nurses participating in a web-based worksite intervention: A randomized controlled trial

Abstract

Background Despite the numerous benefits associated with physical activity (PA), most nurses are not active enough and few interventions have been developed to promote PA among nurses. A secondary analysis of raw data from a single-centre, three-arm parallel-group randomized controlled trial was conducted to assess whether work-related characteristics and general mood states predict changes in total weekly moderate-to-vigorous intensity PA (MVPA) and average daily step-count among nurses participating in a 6-week web-based worksite intervention. Methods Seventy nurses (meanage: 46.1 ± 11.2 years) were randomized to an individual-, friend-, or team-based PA challenge. Participants completed questionnaires pre- and post-intervention assessing work-related characteristics (i.e., shift schedule and length, number of hours worked per week, work role) and general mood states (i.e., tension, depression, anger, confusion, fatigue, vigour). Participants received a PA monitor to wear before and during the 6-week PA challenge, which was used to assess total weekly MVPA minutes and average daily step-count. Data were analyzed descriptively and using multilevel modeling for repeated measures. Results Change in total weekly MVPA minutes, but not change in average daily step-count, was predicted by shift schedule (rotating vs. fixed) by time (estimate = − 17.43, SE = 6.18, p = .006), and work role (clinical-only vs. other) by time (estimate = 18.98, SE = 6.51, p = .005). General mood states did not predict change in MVPA or change in average daily step-count. Conclusions Given that nurses who work rotating shifts and perform clinical work showed smaller improvements in MVPA, it may be necessary to consider work-related factors/barriers (e.g., time constraints, fatigue) and collaborate with nurses when designing and implementing MVPA interventions in the workplace. Trial registration ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT04524572. August 24, 2020. This trial was registered retrospectively. This study adheres to the CONSORT 2010 statement guidelines.

Conceptualizing weight management for night shift workers: A mixed‐methods systematic review

“…Similarly, a physical activity intervention for hospital workers revealed that the attrition rate for shift workers was significantly higher than non‐shift workers ( p = 0.01) 64 . A recent intervention aimed at increasing physical activity for nurses revealed that a subset of nurses working rotational shifts showed smaller improvements in physical activity, with authors speculating that the perception of lack of time and fatigue associated with this work schedule makes increasing physical activity harder to achieve 65 . It is clear that dedicated weight loss interventions for night shift workers are needed with careful consideration of design to address the time constraints barrier, to maximize recruitment, retention, and successful outcomes for participants.…”

Shift workers’ perceptions and experiences of adhering to a nutrition intervention at night whilst working: a qualitative study

“…A study to increase physical activity levels of nurses (n = 70) found that work-related factors (e.g. shift schedule and role type) predicted the change in moderate physical activity achieved 36 . Interventions to support lifestyle behaviour change need to be multicomponent to address causes of workplace stressors 36,37 additional to behavioural-based interventions aimed at mitigating the neuroendocrine abnormalities of circadian disruption [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16]38 .…”

Nurses’ occupational physical activity and workload in a perioperative intensive care unit in Slovenia

“…Benzo, et al ( Benzo et al, 2021 ) reported that nurses who worked day shifts spent more time standing and walking compared to those who worked night shifts, which makes sense given that most medical procedures take place during the day ( Chang and Cho, 2022 ). Shift nurses were found to engage in less moderate to vigorous physical activity on a weekly basis, demonstrating the influence of work-related factors, such as time constraints and fatigue ( Brunet et al, 2021 ). In contrast, in the emergency room, nurses took more steps (9720 ± 4072 steps) during the evening shift due to the high amount of unpredictable work ( Chang and Cho, 2022 ).…”