Women directors and firm performance: Malaysian evidence post policy announcement

Abstract

Purpose In 2011, the Malaysian cabinet approved the policy that all board of directors of companies listed on the Bursa Malaysia should consist of 30 per cent women in decision-making positions by the year 2016. The purpose of this paper is to examine the association between the presence of women on the board and firms’ performance following the introduction of the diversity policy. Design/methodology/approach The analysis uses the information of the top 200 Malaysian public listed companies for the financial year 2011–2013. The multiple regression analysis is used to estimate the relationship between the firm performance (return on assets (ROA)) as the dependent variable and the independent variables. Findings The results show that during the period under study, the proportion of women directors on board is negatively correlated with ROA. This indicates that the firm performance may not be dependent on the number of women directors on board. However, the results of the study also show that the academic backgrounds of the women board members add some value toward generating better firm performance. Research limitations/implications A small sample size of only the top 200 public listed companies was utilised. Consequently the outcome may not be generalisable to smaller public companies or private firms. Another limitation is regarding the sample period. Taking only one year before and one year after the policy’s approval may be too short of the period under study and may be too early to study the impact of the policy. Future studies could sample a longer period. Practical implications The findings encourage public listed companies to appoint women with the necessary qualities as members of the board and not to simply increase the number of women on boards. Originality/value There is a lack of work on studying women’s effectiveness on board in developing countries, whereby previous work and literature review were predominantly based upon the experience of Western economies. This study, thus, contributes to the rising literature on women board member representation based on the firm performance of the top 200 listed companies in Malaysia.

Women in the Boardroom: The Case of Quota vs. Quality

“…The basic knowledge and ability to read, understand, and interpret financial statements will help the board members to better comprehend the complex business transactions and their respective impacts in their decision-making process. This is in line with the conjectures by Ahmad et al (2019), in examining the moderating role of accounting qualifications on the relationship between proportion of women directors and firm performance. In addition, the case of Rolls Royce provides interesting anecdotal evidence on how the lack of accounting and finance representation on the corporate boards contributed to the downfall of the company in 1970's (Mahadeo et al, 2012).…”

Do Female Directors Signal Indian SME IPOs Quality? Evidence From a Quantile Regression Approach

“…Furthermore, in the wake of various corporate collapses and financial catastrophes, like WorldCom and Enron due to dominance of male directors on board, there has been summons for increasing the participation of female on corporate boards (Handa & Singh, 2015; Higgs, 2003). In addition, the advantages of female directors in terms of providing cognitive diversity, creativity, effective monitoring, decision-making through their higher advisory skills and bargaining power has allured upper echelons of listed corporations to increase the female personnel on boards (Ahmad, Raja Kamaruzaman, Hamdan, & Annuar, 2019). Despite the potential advantages of having women on boards, the corporate boards are still prominently being dominated by men calling for an urgent need to staff the board with adequate number of female members.…”

Effect of corporate governance attributes on IFRS compliance: evidence from a developing country

“…Therefore, including them on the board may, in turn, help them to be better monitors over managers' decision-making including financial reporting quality and can also reduce the level of conflict and ensure high quality of board development activities (Agyei-Mensah, 2019). However, the positive performance of women on the board will depend on their academic background and not just merely increasing the numbers (Ahmad et al, 2019). Therefore, having women with financial reporting and auditing expertise on the board can enhance compliance with IFRS.…”