Winter Thermal Comfort and Perceived Air Quality: A Case Study of Primary Schools in Severe Cold Regions in China

Abstract

In Northeast China, most classrooms in primary and secondary schools still use natural ventilation during cold days in winter. This study investigated the thermal comfort and the perceived air quality of children in primary schools in severe cold regions in China. Field measurements were conducted in four typical primary classrooms in two naturally ventilated teaching buildings in the winter of 2016 in the provincial city of Shenyang. Six field surveys were distributed to 141 primary students aged 8 to 11, and 835 valid questionnaires were collected. The results showed that the indoor temperature and the daily mean CO2 concentrations of the primary school classrooms ranged from 17.06 to 24.29 °C and from 1701 to 3959 ppm, respectively. The thermal neutral temperature of the primary school students was 18.5 °C, and the 90% thermal comfort temperature ranged from 17.3 to 20.1 °C. Children were able to respond to changes in indoor air quality, but there was no significant correlation between the children’s perceptions of air quality and the carbon dioxide levels in the classroom. In general, children have a lower comfort temperature than adults. In addition, children are more sensitive to temperature changes during the heating season than adults. Due to differences in thermal sensation between children and adults, the current thermal comfort standard based on adult data is not applicable to primary school buildings and children. The air quality evaluation during heating season indicates that it is necessary to add indoor air environment monitoring instruments and purification equipment to the naturally ventilated classrooms. At present and in the future, more research based on children’s data is needed to solve the indoor air environment problems in primary school buildings.

Thermal Comfort in Buildings: Scientometric Analysis and Systematic Review

“…They have been extensively researched in the literature in different types of buildings, such as nursing homes (Forcada et al, 2021) and educational buildings (B. Yang et al, 2018;Jiang et al, 2018a;Haddad, Osmond and King, 2019;Jindal, 2019;Heracleous and Michael, 2020;Ma et al, 2020;Alonso et al, 2021;Aparicio-Ruiz et al, 2021;Kükrer and Eskin, 2021a;Lamberti et al, 2021;Oh and Song, 2021b;Rodríguez, Coronado and Medina, 2021;Shrestha et al, 2021;Taylor, Brown and Rim, 2021a) health care buildings (Bouzidi et al, 2021) and places of worship (Vella et al, 2021). Although this adaptive approach works better in naturally ventilated buildings, it fails to include some important aspects of the traditional thermal comfort model (Halawa and Van Hoof, 2012).…”

A Review of Thermal Comfort in Primary Schools and Future Challenges in Machine Learning Based Prediction for Children

“…The most frequent finding in both NV and AC classrooms is that applying existing adult-specific thermal comfort benchmarks and clothing values, is not suitable for primary school students [9,36,76,79,81]. Children seem to find the classroom temperature relatively hot and prefer lower temperatures than adults, even in winters [9,76,[79][80][81]. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that thermo-neutrality, or neutral temperature sensations, is a poor indicator of children's thermal comfort [76,79,81].…”

An empirical study of indoor air quality in badminton stadiums in hot summer and cold winter regions of China during spring and fall seasons

“…IAQ has an important impact on human health, although a large number of studies have focused on residential 25 , 26 , office buildings 27 , 28 education in different climate zones buildings 29 , 30 and IAQ in large commercial buildings 31 , 32 but there are fewer relevant studies focusing on sports buildings. In China, stadiums will be built in strict accordance with the design code for sports building JGJ 21-2003 and other national standards for design, and after the stadiums are put into use, with the increase in the number of years of use, the status of IAQ in the pavilion?…”