Windows of opportunity or windows of exclusion? Changing dynamics of tenurial relations in rural Ghana

Abstract

Central to contemporary debates on land tenure in sub-Saharan Africa are questions concerning appropriate pathways to successfully harmonize customary and statutory land tenure arrangements to address normative goals of improving access to land and security of tenure for the poor and marginalized. These are particularly prevalent in the face of increasing commodification and individualisation of land rights. Developing appropriate land policies requires a detailed understanding of existing tenurial dynamics. This paper draws on a mixture of qualitative methods and a household survey among 380 farmers from 19 villages in the Kakum and Ankasa areas of southcentral and western Ghana, to explore the mechanisms of land access, control and ownership arrangements, focusing on key differentiations around gender, age and ethnicity. The results articulate how transformations in land tenure have shifted patterns of accessing land in favour of wealthier individuals to the relative disadvantage of women, young people and poor people regardless of ethnicity. The analysis further indicates that the 'self-transformation' or dynamism of local customary tenure arrangements is inadequate for addressing issues of challenges in access to and control of land, particularly by the vulnerable social groups. This is evidenced by some traditional authorities and local powerful elites capitalizing on the 'new opportunities' afforded by the emergent tenurial relations to advance their individual interests at the expense of the vulnerable groups. Overall, the study highlights how ongoing changes in customary tenure arrangements towards individualisation are far more complex and socially embedded than is often assumed. The paper underscores the need for land policy reforms to shift away from static approaches geared towards promoting efficiency or merely lauding customary tenure arrangements towards more flexible approaches that accommodate the complexity of contemporary changes to land tenure arrangements.

Agricultural Information's Impact on the Adaptive Capacity of Ghana's Smallholder Cocoa Farmers

“…Since female farmers have long been disadvantaged in Ghanaian cocoa cultivation (e.g., Oppong et al, 1975;Quisumbing, 1996;Quisumbing et al, 2001;Baffoe-Asare et al, 2013;Barrientos, 2013;Marston, 2016;Friedman et al, 2018), we set out to examine how female farmers fared in their adaptation to drought. As in many economicallydeveloping agrarian communities, Ghanaian women are systematically disadvantaged since they are generally expected to perform most domestic chores as well as carry out farm labor, and they typically hold fewer land titles (Asaaga and Hirons, 2019). Yet, land-ownership is often a precondition for membership in official farmer organizations, participation in training and information programmes, applying for credit, and managing an adequate diversity of crops (Fountain and Hütz-Adams, 2018).…”

Questioning the link between tenure security and sustainable land management in cocoa landscapes in Ghana

“…As evidenced in Table 2 and Figure 3, the overall results suggest that different land manageme nt strategies (chemical fertiliser application, on-farm tree planting and preservation of naturallyoccurring tree species) 9 were implemented on majority of plots although investment in on-farm tree 9 It is noteworthy that the unique properties of cocoa (relative to other food crops such as maize and cassava) shape household SLM investment behaviour differently. For instance, the longevity and the relatively high market price of cocoa positively affects the quality of land rights to the extent that cocoa farmers may be better -positioned to invest more in say long-term SLM practices (like on-farm tree planting and conservation of naturally-occurring trees) relative to other food crop farmers (see Kolavalli and Vigneri, 2011;Quisumbing et al 2001).…”

“…Preferential rights refer to the right of a landholder to bequeath or transfer land to their next of kin inter vivos as inheritance. Under sharecropping and land rental arrangements, landholders (mostly migrant settler farmers) only have limited rights to occupy and use land for a specified duration subject to certain agreed terms with the landowner (seeAsaaga and Hirons, 2019).…”

Climate-Smart Cocoa in Ghana: How Ecological Modernisation Discourse Risks Side-Lining Cocoa Smallholders

“…However, the myriad legal issues related to tree tenure likely represents the most debilitating factor to achieving pro-poor, equitable CSC. Complexities surrounding tree tenure is not a new phenomenon, but deeply embedded in the Ghanaian cocoa and forestry sector (Ruf, 2011;Hirons et al, 2018a;Asaaga and Hirons, 2019;Bunn et al, 2019). Farmers remain highly uncertain about their legal rights to trees on their own farms.…”