“…Such voices among liberal internationalists are found in Asia as much as the USA -in the works of Mahbubhani (2013) and Tharoor (2012). Scholars of Asian origin in the West, such as Chin and Thakur (2010), approach the question of global power shifts in much the same vein. Charles , despite more radically departing from the complacent hopes of some liberals, nevertheless suggests some retrenchment of US power as a temporary measure only, and lists a range of problems requiring US leadership -rogue states, humanitarian intervention, restraining nuclear proliferation -that as Anderson argues, there is a broad consensus among US and other liberal elites, around the past benefits and future necessity of the post-1945 system, suitably reformed to reflect "the real distribution of power" (Chin and Thakur, 2010, 119).…”