Why don't governments need trade unions anymore? The death of social pacts in Ireland and Italy

Abstract

During the 1990s, a prominent strategy of economic adjustment to the challenges of competitiveness and budgetary retrenchment among the non-corporatist countries of Europe was the negotiation of social pacts. Since the onset of the great recession and the Eurozone crisis, social pacts have been conspicuous by their absence. Why have unions not been invited into government buildings to negotiate paths of economic adjustment in the countries hardest hit by the crisis? Drawing on empirical experiences from Ireland and Italy-two cases on which much of the social pact literature concentrated-this article attributes the exclusion of unions to their declining legitimacy. Unions in the new European periphery have lost the capacity either to threaten governments with the stick of protest or to seduce policymakers with the carrot of problem-solving. They are now seen as a narrow interest group like any other.

Recalibrating Policy Orthodoxy: The IMF Since the Great Recession

“…; Quaglio et al. ) and have done a great deal of damage to democratic accountability (Armingeon and Guthmann ; Blyth ; Culpepper ; Culpepper and Regan ; Offe ; Scharpf ; Schmidt, Schmidt, and Thatcher ; Tomlinson ) . The Fund's role in this crisis management regime saved this institution from its increasing pre‐Lehman irrelevance (Babb ) yet confronted it with the task of dealing with cross‐border banking crises and the attending sovereign default situations in a number of wealthy European countries.…”

Economic causes of the Eurozone crisis: the analytical contribution of Comparative Capitalism

“…117-118), e.g. discusses the failed attempts in Italy and France-particularly given the increasing weakness of unions in the European periphery (Culpepper and Regan, 2014;Hassel, 2015). The alternative option would be a shift towards an LME, obviously the blueprint of the Troika reforms.…”

Changing joint regulation and labour market policy in Italy during the crisis: On the edge of a paradigm shift?

“…Indeed, union officials are highly concerned about their ability to mobilize workers: some respondents said they are facing a representation crisis. This pessimistic assessment is connected to their loss of public legitimacy, reinforced by the decreasing role of concertation and increasing unilateral government intervention in labour market reforms (Culpepper and Regan, 2014). …”