Why do public policy-makers ignore marketing and consumer research? A case study of policy-making for alcohol advertising

Abstract

Public policy-makers have been noted to sometimes ignore marketing/ consumer research, even when the policy issue clearly pertains to consumption markets. We embark to identify factors that may explain policy-makers' limited attention to marketing/consumer research, especially in cases related to consumer affairs that may have public health implications. Empirically, we focus on policy-making around the advertising of alcohol products. Having been involved in this policymaking process in Finland, we elucidate the case through an introspective narrative. We find that the factors explaining policy-makers' limited attention to marketing/consumer research range from the decision-making characteristics of policy-makers, through inconsistent definitions for key terminology, to the fear of over-generalizing certain theories of marketing/consumer research. Regarding the latter, a key issue in the present case was that public policy-makers were unconvinced about the generic marketing theory stating that in mature markets, advertising will not increase the total consumption demand of a product category. ARTICLE HISTORY

Two converging paths: behavioural sciences and social marketing for better policies

“…Against a backdrop of top-down policy-making where individual preferences and behaviours are assumed, both social marketing and behavioural sciences take the citizen as the starting point for building policy interventions. The analysis of the causes of human behaviour is therefore a central feature of both social marketing and behavioural sciences applied to policy (Aspara and Tikkanen, 2017; Shafir, 2013a).…”

Is it easy to get slim? Intention to use slimming products

“…Recently, Aspara and Tikkanen, (2017) have noted the lack of attention given by policymakers to marketing studies involving the public interest, such as public health or consumer affairs. In general, policymakers seem to believe that marketing studies and theories are insufficiently specific, of doubtful scientific validity, and merely serve commercial…”

“…Tikkanen (2017) relataram uma preocupação com a pouca atenção dos gestores públicos com os estudos de marketing que envolvam questões de interesse público, como saúde pública e interesses dos consumidores. Os gestores públicos acreditam que os estudos e teorias do marketing são pouco específicos, servindo meramente para impulsionar interesses comerciais e levantam dúvidas quanto à validade desses estudos.A teoria de intenções de implementação suporta a mensuração da IUE, porque descreve o processo de formação de intenções de atingir um objetivo, como hábitos saudáveis.…”

Analyzing Toyota City’s Eco-policy Through Strategic Marketing Tools

“…Although "social marketing has emerged as a popular and straightforward approach to promote environmental behaviors" (Takahashi, 2009, p. 135), we hardly find literature "adopting a public marketing perspective or particularly focusing on green public services targeted to external stakeholder entities" (Boenigk & Möhlmann, 2016, p. 87). Indeed, public sector marketing receives limited attention (Aspara & Tikkanen, 2016) as public sector organizations find marketing little relevance to their activities (Scrivens, 1991).…”