Why differentiating between health system support and health system strengthening is needed

Abstract

There is increasing recognition that efforts to improve global health cannot be achieved without stronger health systems. Interpretation of health system strengthening (HSS) has varied widely however, with much of the focus to-date on alleviating input constraints, whereas less attention has been given to other performance drivers. It is important to distinguish activities that support the health system, from ones that strengthen the health system. Supporting the health system can include any activity that improves services, from distributing mosquito nets to procuring medicines. These activities improve outcomes primarily by increasing inputs. Strengthening the health system is accomplished by more comprehensive changes to performance drivers such as policies and regulations, organizational structures, and relationships across the health system to motivate changes in behavior and/or allow more effective use of resources to improve multiple health services. Even organizations that have made significant investments in health systems have not provided guidance on what HSS entails. While both supporting and strengthening are important and necessary, it is nonetheless important to make a distinction. If activities fail to produce improvements in system performance because they were incorrectly labeled as system strengthening, the value of HSS investments could quickly be discredited. Not distinguishing supportive activities from strengthening ones will lead to unmet expectations of stronger health systems, as well as neglect of critical system strengthening activities. Distinguishing between these two types of activities will improve programming impact. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Ambulatory tuberculosis treatment in post-Semashko health care systems needs supportive financing mechanisms

“…The MoH of Karakalpakstan and MSF have experienced the need to look beyond addressing existing input gaps, 18 and they are attempting to find health financing mechanisms that support the scale-up of ambulatory anti-tuberculosis treatment. In principle, it seems possible to achieve both a reduction in the number of TB hospital beds and a strengthening of ambulatory TB care within the health financing mechanisms inherited from the Semashko model.…”

Setting the Scene for Post-Ebola Health System Recovery and Resilience in Liberia: Lessons Learned and the Way Forward

“…The current approach focuses on both investing in inputs as well as improving how the health system actually operates. If Liberia must make progress post-Ebola towards achieving Universal Health coverage, the health SDG and health security, building a resilient health system is key [22,23]. The selected investment priorities are quite significant as they reflect the foundations that must be put in place in terms of the capacities and resources needed for sustainable improvements in the health of the people.…”

Constraints to applying systems thinking concepts in health systems: A regional perspective from surveying stakeholders in Eastern Mediterranean countries

“…The World Health Organization's (WHO) Alliance for Health Policy and Systems Research has promoted ST as a strategic approach for health systems strengthening with a view to accelerating progress to achieve global and national health goals (5). However, health systems strengthening is complex, partly because there is no common understanding of what it means, what it involves, and what the most suitable approaches to strengthen health systems are, especially in Low-and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs) (6,7). Moreover, despite increasing examples of why health policies have failed to achieve their targets due to the way policies were designed or implemented (8)(9)(10), actions to address these recurring phenomena and learning from the past are very slow, particularly in LMICs (1,11,12).…”