Whose gain is it anyway? Structurational perspectives on deploying ICTs for development in India's microfinance sector

Abstract

The idea of information and communication technology (ICT) being a "hammer" that can be applied to a wide variety of "nails" across different geographic locations, sectors, organizations, and contexts to improve efficiency and/or have a beneficial social impact has come under severe criticism, particularly in the realm of implementing socioeconomic development programs. Structuration theory remains one of the key metatheories that deconstruct the complexity of technology introductions in the context of organizational and behavioral change. In this study, we use a structurational lens to examine two pilot ICT implementations in the Indian microfinance sector, specifically exploring the interactions between the ICT intervention, the organizations and people implementing the change, and the structural and institutional context within which these projects were rolled out. We showcase how an "ICT for development" intervention is inherently a political process, involving choices around defining efficiency and targeting particular social welfare improvements, with varying repercussions for the involved microfinance institution and client. Where the client's context, constraints, and welfare are placed at the heart of the "efficiency" discussion during the technology's design and implementation, the development impact is seen to be far greater and more sustained. C 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Mobile banking in the government-to-person payment sector for financial inclusion in Pakistan

“…Orlikowski's Duality of Technology (1992) is a well-established framework in the ICT literature for understanding the structuration of technology (Pinsonneault & Kraemer, 2002;De' & Ratan, 2009). Sjöberg (2013) contributes to an understanding of issues and factors that might influence individuals and organizations in their use of, and capabilities to adapt and create, a "new sense" of social media networks.…”

Exploring the Link between ICT and Development in the Context of Developing Countries: A Literature Review

“…For example, the priorities of the dominant caste groups may determine the information systems' design and implementation, which could lead to the exclusion of marginal and non-dominant castes (De & Ratan, 2009). Likewise, an environmental conversion factor means the geographical location, climate, and infrastructure.…”

Managing microfinance with paper, pen and digital slate

“…The cost of investment in the technologyenabled channel is often too high to allow for financial viability over a reasonable timeframe for microfinance institutions [17]. Because application development and testing are often performed in isolation, there have been problems in integrating the prototype solution into regular microfinance workflows given field and operational constraints [18]. Moreover, clients exhibit a strong preference for maintaining a local paper record for reference [10], which has dampened uptake for purely electronic data collection systems, using mobile phones or PDAs, in which a paper trail is not left behind.…”