Who's On the Line? Indian Call Center Agents Pose as Americans for U.S.‐Outsourced Firms

Abstract

This paper explores the globalization of service work through an analysis of customer service call centers in India for U.S. firms. It reveals a new kind of managerial strategy, "national identity management," in which employees are asked to subsume different national identities as part of the job. Through interviews with over eighty Indian call center personnel and case studies of three call centers, this paper analyzes how and why ethnicity and citizenship have become crucial elements of the labor process. It builds upon and elaborates seminal theories of managerial control in interactive service work, including Hochschild's theory of emotion management and Leidner's theory of scripting. It argues that globalization fundamentally alters the relationship of the actors, the purpose and practice of managerial control, and the outcomes for those involved. In addition, it reflects on theories of advancing information and communication technology (ICT), and global identity. Some scholars argue that the development of ICTs will lead to a homogenization (especially an "Americanization") of identities, while others see increasing global disjuncture and renegotiation of identities. Instead, this analysis reveals a continuum of responses by workers to the process of national identity management, and the forging of multiple, internally differentiated ethnic identities. It concludes by arguing that customer service work will continue to be globalized, and as a result, issues of "nation" will increasingly surface within interactive service work.

Worker well-being and the importance of work: Bridging the gap

“…For example, emotional labour that requires frequent suppression of one's true emotions results in feelings of inauthenticity (Erickson and Ritter, 2001), and such instances need to be included in a measure of worker well-being. Other work-related threats to personal identity include being forced to present one's self in certain ways, such as wearing ugly uniforms, following corporate scripts in interacting with customers and being required to suppress one's national identity or class (Leidner, 1993;Poster, 2007). The external recognition and social standing attached to one's work are also important elements of its deeper significance with respect to identity, and should also be considered as part of worker well-being.…”

The “Right” Person for the Job: Exploring the Aesthetics Of Labor Within the Events Industry

“…Telephone-based roles require the right sound, and this increasingly means certain accents and ways of speaking are being devalued and excluded from such types of service sector employment (Cameron, 2000). This may exclude those with strong regional accents, further sidelining individuals from lower socioeconomic groups and ethnic minorities (Cowie, 2007;Poster, 2007).…”

L’expérience de travail en centre d’appels : aux confins de l’engagement et de la distanciation

“…Balisant davantage leur espace de créativité sollicitée dans l'interaction avec le client, cette pratique met en lumière que les comportements des agents doivent impérativement être conformes aux prescriptions hiérarchiques et leur subjectivité est alors assujettie à la néo-taylorisation de la relation de service. Dans les conditions actuelles où plusieurs grandes entreprises occidentales délocalisent leurs centres d'appels vers des pays en développement, cette standardisation de la subjectivité prendrait des proportions jusque-là inexplorées (Poster, 2007;Mirchandani, 2005;Taylor et Bain, 2005) 2 .…”