Who has to act? A qualitative exploration of emerging adults' critical consciousness during the COVID‐19 pandemic

Abstract

The COVID‐19 pandemic and violence against people of Color during 2020 brought troubling racial inequities to the forefront of American discourse. In line with the Critical Consciousness (CC) and Social Justice Youth Development (SJYD) frameworks, emerging adults may have developed their capacity for critical reflection, motivation, and action against systemic inequities. We drew from interviews with 27 emerging adults (ages 18–23) across the US, and used thematic analysis to explore differences in their reflections, motivations to act, and actions based on their racial/ethnic identification. We found nuanced variability in their critical reflections based on self, social, or global awareness and experiences of marginalization. White and Asian emerging adults used vague language or expressed feeling their reflections were insufficient. Black and Latinx emerging adults emphasized the importance of education and raising awareness. Although all emerging adults took action based on a sense of duty, few engaged in critical action; decisions to take in‐person action varied based on whether they viewed racism or COVID‐19 as a greater threat. Findings demonstrate that emerging adults' experiences of racialization may have related to their CC development. We share implications for community psychologists conducting antiracist research addressing White fragility and dismantling racial hierarchy.

A Black feminist study of freedom, community care, and self-definition among Black college women attending predominantly White institutions.

“…Second, college should be a period of personal exploration and self-discovery when students learn more about who they are and how they want to contribute to society (Leath, Ball, et al, 2022; Porter et al, 2020; Quiles et al, 2023). To have this period of personal exploration and self-discovery, the women discussed the importance of having (and creating) counterspaces where they could experience recognition and care, removed from the weight of stereotypical judgments and expectations.…”

A preliminary investigation of longitudinal associations between ethnic–racial identity and critical consciousness among Black and Latinx youth.

“…Thus, parent reports of their families' total income were included as an additional covariate. Finally, given that youth participated in the study during the COVID-19 pandemic-a time that provided young people an opportunity to further reckon with race and racism in the United States (Quiles et al, 2023)-youths' reports of whether they attended school in person or remotely/in a hybrid option were also included as a covariate.…”

The racialized landscape of COVID-19:Reverberations for minority adolescents and families in the U.S.

“…Civic engagement is another coping strategy for racial/ethnic minority youth in response to oppressive systems of inequity [ 47 ]. Studies of diverse emerging adults and adolescents showcase their critical consciousness around how racial inequalities shaped COVID-19 and racial tensions during the pandemic, which motivated more acts of direct service and participation in social justice movements [ 48 , 49 ].…”