Who Had Faith in Sociology? Scholarly and Ideological Divergences in Belgium around 1900

Abstract

ArgumentThis paper examines the early institutionalization of sociology in Belgium. It displays how different intellectual and social contexts bred their own research interests and research approaches. It shows, more particularly, how ideological affiliations and divisions defined the setting within which this new discipline had to develop in Belgium in the decades around 1900. As a consequence of the ideological controversies, sociology had difficulty gaining legitimacy as a theory-driven analysis of society. Most scholars in Belgium could not avoid taking an explicitly normative position on society. This paper also displays how secularization and the reinforcement of the international level and its infrastructure gradually allowed for more academic autonomy for sociology in Belgium.

The Local versus the Global in the history of relativity: The case of Belgium

“…This sheds light on the changing roles of science in Belgian society during the turbulent first decades of the twentieth century (building on excellent recent work, e.g. Vanderstraeten 2018;Onghena 2011;Wils 2005;Tollebeek et al 2003). Ultimately, I address how Belgian perspectives on relativity to and intertwined with those in other countries, as to identify transnational networks and global patterns in the history of relativity.…”

Belgium and probability in the nineteenth century: The case of Paul Mansion

“…This is not the first study to focus on the significance of the Belgian setting as a means of approaching the history of an academic discipline. Both Wils and Rasmussen (2012) and Vanderstraeten (2018), for instance, have done so in the context of sociology. Vanderstraeten (2018) describes in detail how several institutions were created within Belgian public, religious, and anti-religious universities in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century to support or oppose sociology.…”

“…Both Wils and Rasmussen (2012) and Vanderstraeten (2018), for instance, have done so in the context of sociology. Vanderstraeten (2018) describes in detail how several institutions were created within Belgian public, religious, and anti-religious universities in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century to support or oppose sociology. The members of these institutions had to position themselves with respect to the situation in neighboring countries (e.g.…”

Making science international: Chilean journals and communities in the world of science

“…Expansion into the international sphere provided scholars with opportunities to consolidate or improve their own positioning (e.g. Kreuder-Sonnen, 2016; Vanderstraeten, 2018). The articulation of the universalist ethos of science also made clear that national communities and national traditions were embedded within broader, global settings.…”