Who am I? Key influences on the formation of academic identity within a faculty development program

Abstract

Introduction: Professional identity encompasses how individuals understand themselves, interpret experiences, present themselves, wish to be perceived, and are recognized by the broader professional community. For health professional and health science educators, their 'academic' professional identity is situated within their academic community and plays an integral role in their well being and productivity. This study aims to explore factors that contribute to the formation and growth of academic identity (AI) within the context of a longitudinal faculty development program. Methods: Using a qualitative case study approach, data from three cohorts of a 2-year faculty development program were explored and analyzed for emerging issues and themes related to AI. Results: Factors salient to the formation of AI were grouped into three major domains: personal (cognitive and emotional factors unique to each individual); relational (connections and interactions with others); and contextual (the program itself and external work environments). Discussion: Faculty development initiatives not only aim to develop knowledge, skills, and attitudes, but also contribute to the formation of academic identities in a number of different ways. Facilitating the growth of AI has the potential to increase faculty motivation, satisfaction, and productivity. Faculty developers need to be mindful of factors within the personal, relational, and contextual domains when considering issues of program design and implementation.

Making the leap to medical education: a qualitative study of medical educators' experiences

“…There is no doubt, however, that moving into medical education represents a major and occasionally painful career transition that profoundly affects the individual's sense of his or her working identity. The literature reports an almost universal experience among educators of periods of frustration, disappointment, stress, demoralisation and burnout, coupled with a lingering sense of loss at the erosion of their primary professional identity . Furthermore, although there are few data to show how many of those who express a desire to teach actually go on to develop a significant medical education career, we do know that for most medical schools the retaining of teaching staff is a major challenge, with 42% of medical school faculty in one study expressing ‘serious intent to leave’ …”

Logros más alla de los objetivos: evaluación cualitativa de un programa de formación en educación médica

“…Estos hallazgos confirman lo encontrado por otras investigaciones: Knight concluye que programas de formación de docentes en educación médica pueden tener efectos amplios y duraderos en el desarrollo intra e interpersonal, así como también en la carrera docente 6 . Lieff plantea que la capacitación docente puede tener un impacto en los "valores humanistas" de los académicos y puede alentar la reflexión sobre el sentido de ser docente y sobre la búsqueda de la realización como profesional 17 , lo cual contribuye al desafío de retener alos académicos y consolidar un grupo altamente motivado con un sentido de pertenencia a su institución 18,19 .…”

Developing and rewarding teachers as educators and scholars: remarkable progress and daunting challenges

“…Teachers undergo changes in their personal and professional identities, as they co‐construct their identities as educators within their organisational environments. Integrating educator roles into their identities occurs over time, influencing their choices about whether to engage in more teaching and in faculty development . Acknowledging these more expansive roles of educators offers greater opportunities to recognise the various contributions of educators to the educational mission.…”

“…They give credence to the social and political contexts that influence teaching and learning. They can also help with identity formation as educators …”