When Discounts Hurt Sales: The Case of Daily-Deal Markets

Abstract

We investigate whether the discounts offered by online daily deals help attract consumer purchases. By tracking the sales of 19,978 deals on Groupon.com and conducting a battery of identification and falsification tests, we find that deep discounts reduce sales. A one-percent increase in a deal's discount decreases sales by 0.035-0.256 percent. If a merchant offers 10 percent more discount from the sample mean of 55.6 percent, the sales could decrease by 0.63-4.60 percent, or 0.80-5.24 units and $42-$275 in revenue. This negative effect of discount is more prominent among credence goods and deals with low sales, and when the deals are offered in cities with higher income and better education. Our findings suggest that consumers are concerned about product quality and excessive discounts may reduce sales immediately. A follow-up lab experiment provides further support to this quality concern explanation. Furthermore, it suggests the existence of a "threshold", viz. the negative effect on sales is present only when the discount is sufficiently high. Additional empirical analysis shows that deals displaying favorable third-party support, such as Facebook fans and online reviews, are more susceptible to this adverse discount effect. We draw related managerial implications.

When and How to Leverage E-commerce Cart Targeting: The Relative and Moderated Effects of Scarcity and Price Incentives with a Two-Stage Field Experiment and Causal Forest Optimization

“…However, in an early shopping stage with empty carts, consumers are still browsing or comparing products in a deliberative mindset. In this situation, the same price discounts may signal lower quality products (Blattberg and Neslin 1990, Rossi et al 1996, Jedidi et al 1999, Cao et al 2018. Unlike off-line shopping when consumers can touch, experience, and try the product in physical stores, online shopping prevents customers from evaluating the quality of the product prior to purchase (Dimoka et al 2012).…”

Information Cascades and Online Shopping

“…The mixed results found in earlier studies (Cao et al, 2018;Dhar et al, 2007;Erdem et al, 2008;Rao & Monroe, 1989;Xu and Huang, 2014) could be potentially explained by informational cascades theory, which gives an indication that the complexity of relationship between price discounts and product sales is underestimated than previously thought. Instead of suggesting price discounts offers a uniform influence on products, informational cascades theory indicates that the influence is moderated by the level of informational cascades when customers make purchase decisions.…”

Understanding the “Holiday Effect” in Online Restaurant Ratings

“…Prior literature has studied the holiday effect in various fields, especially the stock market [17,18], marketing (e.g. consumer behavior) [19,20], tourism [21], etc. Most of these studies find a positive holiday effect, indicating that individuals are more likely to be in a good mood on holidays [22].…”