When Contact Is Not Enough: Affecting First Year Medical Students’ Image towards Older Persons

Abstract

ContextMany medical schools have initiated care internships to familiarize their students with older persons and to instil a professional attitude.ObjectiveTo examine the impact of care internships on the image that first-year medical students have of older persons and to explore the underlying concepts that may play a role in shaping this image.DesignSurvey before and after a two-week compulsory care internship using the Aging Semantic Differential (ASD; 32 adjectives) and the Attitudes toward Old People (AOP; 34 positions) questionnaires.ParticipantsBefore and after a care internship involving interpersonal contact, 252 and 244 first-year medical students at the Leiden University Medical Centre (LUMC) in the academic year 2012–2013 participated.MethodDescriptive statistics, analyses of variance, and principal component analysis were used; clusters of adjectives and positions were reduced into concepts to examine dominant patterns of views. Changes in image were investigated as mean differences of the total and concept scores.ResultsBoth the ASD and the AOP questionnaires showed a poor general image of older persons that significantly worsened after the care internship (p < 0.01). The percentage of students considering over 75 years as being old increased from 17.2% to 31.2% (p < 0.01) and those who thought they would find as much satisfaction in care for older as for younger patients decreased from 78.5% to 62.1% (p < 0.001). Exploratory principal component analysis showed particularly low scores on ‘comportment’ and ‘pleasurable interaction’ whereas the scores on ‘personality traits’ and ‘habitual behaviour’ significantly deteriorated (both p < 0.001). These patterns were irrespective of the student’s gender and previous contact experience.ConclusionMedical schools should carefully consider care internships to ensure that students do not worsen their views on older patients, which may occur due to inadequate contact depth and quality within a rather unsupportive context.

Implicit attitudes toward the elderly among health professionals and undergraduate students in the health field: a systematic review

“…[2][3][4][5] Conversely, studies have revealed that health professionals and students in the health field prefer not to work with the elderly. 6,7 A study involving 113 nursing students found that only 2.7% reported having interest in working with this target public, whereas 68.1% reported having no interest and the rest demonstrated neither interest nor disinterest. 6 In another study involving 100 neurologists, 77% had positive attitudes toward the elderly, 20% had negative attitudes and the remaining 3% had neutral attitudes.…”

Who Should Interview Older People? The Effect of Interviewer and Interviewee Characteristics in Surveys of Older People and Aging Topics

“…(Rodgers -Herzog 1995: 151) Exposure to problems and difficult issues may represent an additional source of distress (cf. Kusumastuti et al 2017;White 2001), especially if, regardless of the interviewer´s own age, his or her attitudes towards old age, older people, and / or aging are inflicted with ageism. (Greenberg et al 2004) The rising numbers of older people in the global north and the quest for evidence-based policies have increased the demand for valid and reliable sociological data on various aging topics.…”

Preparing for the future: The changing demographic composition of hospital patients in Denmark between 2013 and 2050

“…A growing body of recent literature has reported that medical students and student nurses tend to have negative attitudes towards older individuals [10][11][12]. Working with older patients has often been described as a burden and as less satisfying than working with younger patients.…”