What Would You Do? Types of Ethical Challenging Situations Depicted in Vignettes Published in the Veterinary Literature from 1990 to 2020

Abstract

Veterinary team members encounter a wide range of ethically challenging situations (ECS) in their work. Inability to resolve ECS in accordance with their values may negatively impact the wellbeing of veterinary team members. We sought to determine the types of ECS described in published ethical vignettes in the veterinary literature. We performed a strategic literature search, followed by a thematic analysis of vignettes published in the veterinary literature from 1990–2020. We identified 567 published vignettes in 544 publications. In the majority of vignettes, the protagonist was a veterinarian (61.6%) and the most common categories of animal involved were dogs (28.0%), livestock in general (10.8%), and cattle (10.6%). The primary type of ECS was coded for each scenario, generating 29 themes. These findings extend knowledge about types of ECS that may be encountered by veterinary team members. These themes can help to inform curricula and better prepare veterinary team members to navigate ECS. They may also highlight factors that contribute to ECS that can be addressed on a broad scale, such as through regulation, continuing professional development, or stakeholder education. Knowing that others may experience similar ECS may help veterinary team members feel part of a moral community.

“There Was a Sense That Our Load Had Been Lightened”: Evaluating Outcomes of Virtual Ethics Rounds for Veterinary Team Members

“…A comprehensive discussion of the types of ECS identified by participants is beyond the scope of this paper, however we note that these were consistent with ECS identified in the veterinary ethics literature ( 1 – 5 , 7 , 32 , 54 ). Consistent with published literature, respondents confirmed that ECS had a negative and sometimes long-lasting impact on them ( 63 ), that there are numerous barriers to resolving ECS ( 64 ), and that there are some factors—such as the legal status of animals as property in most jurisdictions—which increase the risk of encountering ECS ( 65 ).…”

“…For the types of ECS discussed in sessions, as recorded by the facilitator, a codebook analysis was utilized. We used codes developed in a previous thematic analysis of ECS depicted in published vignettes ( 54 ). Each ECS was coded once, and coding frequencies recorded.…”

Embracing clinical ethics support services in the UK veterinary profession

“…Think of the last time you treated a patient and felt obliged to follow a certain course, not because you thought that it was in the best interests of the animal, but because of finances, resources or pressure from colleagues or clients – you were facing an ‘ethically challenging situation’ (ECS), something that multiple surveys have found to be common among veterinary team members (Quain and others 2021).…”

Ethical challenges experienced by veterinary practitioners in relation to adverse events: Insights from a qualitative study

“…53 ECs relevant to adverse event occurrence that have previously been identified within vignettes published in the veterinary literature include those related to managing errors and complications and working with or assisting team members who are providing incompetent care. 54 Although vignettes or case scenarios may be used to exemplify experiences, the extent to which they reflect real life is unknown. Understanding veterinary practitioners' real-life experiences of ethically challenging elements of adverse events is necessary to inform strategies that mitigate adverse events and associated emotional consequences.…”

“…ECs relevant to adverse event occurrence that have previously been identified within vignettes published in the veterinary literature include those related to managing errors and complications and working with or assisting team members who are providing incompetent care 54 . Although vignettes or case scenarios may be used to exemplify experiences, the extent to which they reflect real life is unknown.…”