What qualitative research can tell us about performance management systems

Abstract

International audiencePurpose – This paper aims to focus on the use of qualitative research methods to gain a better understanding of the performance management system (PMS) of one of the largest retailers in NorthAmerica. The motivation for the research was to assess whether the PMS at one of the world’s largest retail companies was congruent with the most recent thinking and research in the management accounting literature.Design/methodology/approach – Using open-ended interviews, the paper seeks to develop relevant hypotheses emerging from the dimensions of the Strauss and Corbin’s qualitative research methodology (1998). A qualitative methodology was used because it provides a structured approachand analytical techniques that can build upon existing theory and literature.Findings – The qualitative evidence collected during the course of the research indicates that financial measures were predominantly used by the company in its PMS, and that this reliance on financial measures may be an artifact of the industry in which the company operates. The retail industry is highly competitive, and it is very sensitive to changes in customer tastes and behavior, as well as shareholder and financial market pressures. In addition to financial measures, it was found that operational management developed certain non-financial performance measures and that this development may have been a response by operational managers to wider stakeholder pressures and external influences.However, these performance measures appear to be not fully integrated in the PMS and are therefore de-coupled and relatively unimportant in, or entirely absent from, top-level decision-making.Research limitations and implications – The conclusions of the paper provide support for the concepts of isomorphism and de-coupling as found in the literature of new institutional theory.Originality/value – The case study approach has enabled to explore and gain further understanding of management accounting practices, particularly performance measurement and management, in their natural setting. Strauss and Corbin’s (1998) grounded theory methodology was adopted because it provides a structured set of analytical steps and systematic analytical techniques for handling and interpreting data and theory building

Qualitative research in accounting: the North American perspective

“…A qualitative study of a performance management system in the retail industry The fourth paper in the Special Issue was written by Bruno Cohanier of the Neoma Business School in France (Cohanier, 2014). The connection with North American qualitative accounting research is that the paper is a long case study of one of the world's largest retail companies which is headquartered in the USA.…”

Sustainability Strategy and Management Control Systems in Family Firms. Evidence from a Case Study

“…This is also the case of the case study methodology, which plays a particularly important role among qualitative methods [63]. Instead, qualitative orientation offers particular value at the organization-specific level; it is at this level that most managers and management accountants make decisions and act; it is at this highly contextualized and situationally specific level that they seek policy and practice insights [64][65][66]. For these reasons, a case study methodology has been used to investigate the issue of the pathway of sustainability integration in a family firm.…”

Co-opetition for corporate social responsibility and sustainability: drivers and success factors

“…considering all stakeholders). Consequently, a qualitative research approach was adopted for this study as there is a The businesses (including co-opetitors), consumer groups, environmentalists and other stakeholders that make up the alliance developed a set of goals and principles for environmental performance (Lee, 2008) Corporate social responsibility need to understand new and complex phenomena related to sustainability performance (Abdalla and Ak, 2015;Cohanier, 2014;Crofts and Bisman, 2010;Sciulli, 2011;Yami and Nemeh, 2014). This study aims to understand three different aspects of this new phenomenon:…”