What Motivates Innovative Entrepreneurs? Evidence from a Global Field Experiment

Abstract

Entrepreneurial motivation is important to the process of economic growth. However, evidence on the motivations of innovative entrepreneurs, and how those motivations differ across fundamental characteristics, remains scant. We conduct three interrelated field experiments with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Inclusive Innovation Challenge to study how innovative entrepreneurs respond to messages of money and social impact and how this varies across gender and culture. We find consistent evidence that women and individuals located in more altruistic cultures are more motivated by social-impact messages than money, whereas men and those in less altruistic cultures are more motivated by money than social impact. The estimates are not driven by differences in the type of company, its size, or other observable characteristics, but, instead, appear to come from differences in the underlying motivations of innovative entrepreneurs themselves. This paper was accepted by Joshua Gans, business strategy.

Nonmonetary Incentives and the Implications of Work as a Source of Meaning

“…Hence, consistent with previous work on intrinsic motivation (like Besley and Ghatak 2005), identity theory (Akerlof and Kranton 2005), and behavioral contracting with reciprocal agents (Englmaier and Leider 2012), job meaning is likely to flatten the optimal wage schedule, emphasizing the role of substitution between job meaning and performance-based monetary incentives. 2 Given budget constraints, firms compare the marginal return of monetary incentives on effort to the marginal return of nonmonetary incentives. Several experiments have compared the relative impact of offering more money versus offering higher pro-social mission in the form of higher charitable donations.…”

Evolving as an entrepreneur: a life story approach to studying Indian women entrepreneurs

“…Women in our sample also appeared to be most strongly driven by wanting to make the lives of others better by sharing the produce of their labor. Driven by the strong Indian value of daan (altruism), which states that one's labor must be directed to uplift others, this is in consonance with research that finds women are driven by social contribution, especially in altruistic cultures (Guzman et al, 2020).…”

Altruism and female entrepreneurship: evidence from the Turkish community in Kosovo

“…In quantitative research, data are gathered to quantify information and statistically analyze it to confirm or deny "alternate knowledge claims" (Creswell, 2003). Apart from their importance for natural Turkish community in Kosovo sciences, quantitative methods have become important criteria for social sciences as well (Grbich, 2007). Given that questionnaires are the most popular method for gathering data in quantitative studies (Bryman, 2006), it was opted to use a fully structured questionnaire.…”

“…Most of studies indicate that women are more altruistic than men (Brañas-Garza et al, 2018;Coulter et al, 2007;Duman, 2021;Khalınbaylı and Tas , 2019;Simmons and Emanuele, 2007). In addition to this Guzman et al (2020) stated that female entrepreneurs and individuals living in more altruistic cultures were motivated more by social influence messages rather than money, whereas male entrepreneurs and those living in less altruistic cultures were motivated more by money than social influence.…”