What Is the Use of a Single-Case Study in Management Research?

Abstract

Para que serve um estudo de caso único na pesquisa de gestão? ¿Para qué sierve un estudio de caso único en la investigación de gestión?ABSTRACT The purpose of this article is to present a defense of the use of single case studies in management research. The defense is necessary because this type of research has been relegated to a secondary role, or even rejected, by many researchers, who consider it unscientific. Evidence of this low status is the fact that most reputable academic journals in management publish few articles based on single-case studies. In this paper, we examine in detail the objections to the use of such cases in management research. We show the efforts made by some researchers to answer these objections and we show quality criteria for research that are alternatives to the criteria used in the so-called "scientific method." Our analysis suggests that a better understanding -by researchers with different methodological preferences -of the arguments for each particular use of the single-case study as a research method would allow a better dialogue between researchers and benefit management research as a whole. KEYWORDS | Management research, single-case study, research methodology, scientific method, knowledge acquisition. RESUMO RAE-Revista de Administração de Empresas | FGV-EAESP

Education in cooperative cells as a social innovation: a case study in the Brazilian semiarid

“…In order to attain greater methodological rigour for the case studied, as suggested Mariotto, Zanni, and Moraes (2014), there was an effort to refine and interpret the data collected by employing the content analysis technique via the software NVivo 10. This tool permitted to reach more respectability in the process of analysis, although keeping a positivistic focus, but maintaining the importance of the case's specificities.…”

Sustainability Assessment of logistics activities in a dairy: An example of an emerging economy

“…This research is empirical by gathering data collected in the field through structured interviews, conducting a documentary analysis of literature, and internal documents provided by the organization. The collection of data of diverse types contributes to the reliability, allowing the interaction between the diverse sources of evidence and supporting the propositions (Mariotto et al, 2014). The data are quantitative in the function of the types of variables collected and are represented descriptively, establishing the causal relationship when possible (Miles et al, 2018).…”

Fatores críticos de sucesso à adoção de GSCM: estudo de casos no setor de baterias automotivas

“…This method has been widely used by researchers aiming to contribute to the acquisition and dissemination of knowledge (Mariotto et al, 2014) since, according to the literature reviewed, this is a consistent research method commonly used for analysis and comparison of data and information (Voss et al, 2002). Kim & Rhee (2012) recommend the use of qualitative case studies when investigating critical success factors for GSCM adoption; therefore, this was the research method chosen in the present study.…”