What Is New about Dutch Populism? Dutch Colonialism, Hierarchical Citizenship and Contemporary Populist Debates and Policies in the Netherlands

Abstract

This article discusses how Dutch politics of citizenship in the (colonial) past and the present create distinctions, distribute status, rights, opportunities, securities and wealth and how they evoke agency. This process is analysed first by exploring the politics of citizenship in colonial times; second, the implications of political decolonisation for citizenship are discussed; third, present day dynamics around Dutch populism and how they connect to autochthony and Islamophobia are discussed; fourth, a present-day example of the phenomenon termed 'citizenship alienism' will be analysed. These historical and contemporary discourses demonstrate how through the years, Dutch majoritarian politicians have constructed a distinction between 'conditional' versus 'unconditional' citizens through references to a mythical core Dutch nation. The politics of inequality under populism are in that sense not new, but, rather, present-day expressions of a much older Dutch political phenomenon.

Sister Outsider and Audre Lorde in the Netherlands: On Transnational Queer Feminisms and Archival Methodological Practices

“…Maarten and the former Cape Colony in South Africa. Within the present-day Dutch Kingdom, there is a violent colonial construction of citizenship, which requires an analysis of who constitutes a citizen within the Dutch imaginary (see Jones, 2012Jones, , 2016. This division in the Dutch imaginary relates to the long use of the terms 'allochtoon' (meaning from elsewhere, i.e.…”

“…The Dutch empire comprised what is now known as Indonesia (previously referred to as the ‘Dutch East Indies’); territories in ‘the West Indies’, including Suriname; and the Caribbean Islands of Aruba, Curacao, Bonaire, Saba, St. Eustacius, St. Maarten and the former Cape Colony in South Africa. Within the present-day Dutch Kingdom, there is a violent colonial construction of citizenship, which requires an analysis of who constitutes a citizen within the Dutch imaginary (see Jones, 2012, 2016). This division in the Dutch imaginary relates to the long use of the terms ‘ allochtoon ’ (meaning from elsewhere, i.e.…”

“…). The ‘instabilities of citizenship’, which Guno Jones (2016, p. 606) contends with in his work, trouble the geopolitical understanding of place within the Dutch Kingdom (Jordan, 2014; Wekker, 2016). Sister Outsider’s writing also grappled with processes of exclusion to make sense of what it meant to inhabit space in the Netherlands.…”

Anxious Politics in Postcolonial Europe

“…Europe's nations, with their provisions of housing, jobs, and even heritage, come to be seen as owned by their white citizens. These distributions of belonging evoke Europe's colonial history and imperial ambitions and imaginations (Jones ). For nonwhite citizens, always regarded as migrants, to make claims to these goods contributes to fashioning anxiety.…”

Special Section on Nativism, Nationalism, and Xenophobia: What Anthropologists Do and Have Done

“…Europe's nations, with their provisions of housing, jobs, and even heritage, come to be seen as owned by their white citizens. These distributions of belonging evoke Europe's colonial history and imperial ambitions and imaginations (Jones 2016). For nonwhite citizens, always regarded as migrants, to make claims to these goods contributes to fashioning anxiety.…”