What Holds Attention? Linguistic Drivers of Engagement

Abstract

From advertisers and marketers to salespeople and leaders, everyone wants to hold attention. They want to make ads, pitches, presentations, and content that captivates audiences and keeps them engaged. But not all content has that effect. What makes some content more engaging? A multi-method investigation combines controlled experiments with natural language processing of 600,000 reading sessions from over 35,000 pieces of content to examine what types of language hold attention and why. Results demonstrate that linguistic features associated with processing ease (e.g., concrete or familiar words) and emotion both play an important role. Rather than simply being driven by valence, though, the effects of emotional language are driven by the degree to which different discrete emotions evoke arousal and uncertainty. Consistent with this, anxious, exciting, and hopeful language holds attention while sad language discourages it. Experimental evidence underscores emotional language’s causal impact and demonstrates the mediating role of uncertainty and arousal. The findings shed light on what holds attention, illustrates how content creators can generate more impactful content, and, as shown in a stylized simulation, have important societal implications for content recommendation algorithms.

Better abstract or concrete, narrating or not: optimal strategies for the communication of innovation

“…Lastly, future research could explore the effects of abstractness (vs concreteness) and narrativity on other outcomes. For example future studies may focus on metrics of attention (Berger et al ., 2023) or on the type of interaction generated by the content of communication, performing text analysis on the comments (e.g. Unnava and Aravindakshan, 2021).…”

“…Consumer language research has demonstrated that linguistic features associated with emotions play an important role in driving user engagement (e.g. Berger et al, 2023). We consider the emotional tone of a text as a psycholinguistic variable, which summarizes the presence of positive and negative emotions in a text and varies from very negative tone to very positive tone.…”

Quantifying cultural change: Gender bias in music.

“…These emerging approaches have the potential to shed light on a range of interesting questions (Berger et al, 2023; Berger & Packard, 2022; Boghrati et al, 2023). Take the ongoing debate about the universality of emotions.…”

Unveiling the dark side of influencer marketing: how social media influencers (human vs virtual) diminish followers’ well-being

“…Prior research has used text mining to measure well-being in terms of positive and negative emotions, typically using the Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) dictionarybased technique to identify emotions such as anger, anxiety and sadness. However, concerns have been raised about the reliability of this approach for capturing unique emotions (Berger et al, 2023). Therefore, instead of using LIWC to measure followers' negative emotions and relied on an approach developed by Mohammad and Bravo-Marquez (2017) to measure anger, anxiety and sadness.…”