What Governance Failures Reveal about Water Resources Management in a Municipality of Brazil

Abstract

Humans have historically chosen to develop their cities close to rivers due to the need for water and food security. In Brazil, water security represents a growing challenge, despite advances in the National Water Resources Management System. While municipalities are responsible for integrating the various public policies that impact urban rivers, such as the environment, basic sanitation, and urban planning, only states and the federal government, along with watershed committees, have a formal role in the National Water Resources Management System. The goal of this paper is to assess the Brazilian water governance system from the perspective of municipalities. The OECD water governance framework is applied to a medium-sized Brazilian municipality (c. 200,000 inhabitants), Itabuna, Bahia state, through perception-based and objective data. Studies dealing with water governance do not address this reality, despite representing more than 90% Brazilian municipalities and approximately half of the country’s population. Several water governance failures were identified, such as connections between administrative and political failures, which highlight the tragic consequences of hydrological issues in this region. Developing integrated water resources’ management, as fixed in national and state laws, depends on the effective participation of the municipality. This study discusses the importance of water governance at the municipal scale.

Integrated water resources management in an urban concept: results from water smart cities and water management institutions in Slovakia

“…These standards should be harmonised both with existing legislation governing water resources management and for conceptualising Smart Cities. Hydrological issues may arise unless political and administrative aspects are harmonised (Nicollier et al, 2022).…”

Gestión ambiental municipal, ocupación territorial y percepción del buen vivir, Ayacucho, Perú

“…En esa misma línea, (Garbaccio et al, 2021), hicieron un análisis de los resultados de los procesos de ordenamiento territorial como principal eje de desarrollo local en el municipio brasileño de Montenegro en Río Grande do Sul. Pusieron en tapete las condiciones legales impuestas desde el gobierno central y la legitimidad del empoderamiento de la gestión ambiental local concluyendo que, si bien el ordenamiento territorial ha dado buenos resultados en la ocupación de los espacios, es necesario que las autoridades actúen estratégicamente para empoderar a las personas en un modelo de autogestión del territorio con una visión sustentable, sobre todo en los recursos en los cuales depende la producción sostenible alimentaria, como también lo propusieron (Nicollier et al, 2022) y (Neumann & Hack, 2019), al evaluar profundamente las fallas de la gobernanza municipal respecto a la gestión de los recursos hídricos en el territorio como elemento básico que fundamenta la riqueza y desarrollo de ese territorio.…”