What do young people think about their school-based sex and relationship education? A qualitative synthesis of young people's views and experiences

Abstract

ObjectivesAlthough sex and relationship education (SRE) represents a key strand in policies to safeguard young people and improve their sexual health, it currently lacks statutory status, government guidance is outdated and a third of UK schools has poor-quality SRE. We aimed to investigate whether current provision meets young people's needs.DesignSynthesis of qualitative studies of young people's views of their school-based SRE.SettingEligible studies originated from the UK, Ireland, the USA, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, Japan, Iran, Brazil and Sweden.ParticipantsStudies of students aged 4–19 in full-time education, young adults ≤19 (not necessarily in full-time education) or adults ≤25 if recalling their experiences of school-based SRE.Results–69 publications were identified, with 55 remaining after quality appraisal (representing 48 studies). The synthesis found that although sex is a potent and potentially embarrassing topic, schools appear reluctant to acknowledge this and attempt to teach SRE in the same way as other subjects. Young people report feeling vulnerable in SRE, with young men anxious to conceal sexual ignorance and young women risking sexual harassment if they participate. Schools appear to have difficulty accepting that some young people are sexually active, leading to SRE that is out of touch with many young people's lives. Young people report that SRE can be negative, gendered and heterosexist. They expressed dislike of their own teachers delivering SRE due to blurred boundaries, lack of anonymity, embarrassment and poor training.ConclusionsSRE should be ‘sex-positive’ and delivered by experts who maintain clear boundaries with students. Schools should acknowledge that sex is a special subject with unique challenges, as well as the fact and range of young people's sexual activity, otherwise young people will continue to disengage from SRE and opportunities for safeguarding and improving their sexual health will be reduced.

Student health and well-being in secondary schools: the role of school support staff alongside teaching staff

“…Indeed, to date, much literature on the role of school staff in supporting student well-being has tended to reduce ‘school staff’ to ‘teachers’ and ignore the growing array of support roles within schools and their potential roles in facilitating student well-being (Van Petegem, Aelterman, Van Keer, & Rosseel, 2008). In contrast, several research articles have highlighted incongruence between the power imbalance within a teacher–student relationship and the dynamics required to address health and well-being-related issues, with staff other than classroom teachers perhaps playing important roles in connecting students to their school and supporting well-being (Bishop, Whitear, & Brown, 2001; Pound, Langford, & Campbell, 2016). …”

Evaluation of Strategies for the Prevention of HIV and STIs in Spanish Adolescents

“…and parents, compared to other studies [18]. These data can be related to the negative perception that adolescents have about sex education, feeling her as shameful and distant from their interests [21]. Draws attention how some point to obtain that information from the pornography, taking into account that they are all underage; or of the nature, which implies that given by known knowledge that they do not possess.…”

Educator–student communication in sex & relationship education: a comparison of teacher and peer-led interventions

“…Restricting communication in this way is 'unlikely to result in a comfortable experience for either teachers or pupils, nor is it likely to achieve positive behavioural change' (Buston, Wight, & Scott, 2001, 367). The nature of teacher-student relationships create discomfort on the part of both teachers and students within SRE (Allen, 2005;Langille et al, 2001;Lester & Allan, 2006;Pound, Langford, & Campbell, 2016). These problems are attributed to the conflicting social worlds of adult teachers and adolescent students being forced into open confrontation in the SRE classroom (Allen, 2001;Langille et al, 2001).…”