Western humanism, African humanism and work organisations

Abstract

Comparison of Western (WH) and African humanism (AH) shows overlapping and complementary approaches to human nature in work organisations. The extant literature is conceptually, empirically and methodologically inadequate, and fails to consider 21st century employment realities. Shortcomings of WH and AH are presented. A dynamic and mutualistic approach to human nature, that includes both self-assertive (individualist) and self transcending (collectivist) tendencies, is briefly outlined. It provides a more comprehensive approach to humanism, for better understanding of human behaviour at work. There is currently too much rhetoric in the field. More research, especially the use of qualitative and narrative interpretive methodologies is required.
 
 <b>Opsomming</b>
 Vergelyking van Westerse (WH) met Afrika (AH) opvattings oor humanisme in werkorganisasies toon, verskille ten spyt, dat oorvleueling en aanvullende benaderingsmoontlikhede bestaan. Die betrokke literatuur is tans konseptueel, empiries en metodologies onvoldoende. Moderne indiensnemingsrealiteite word ook nie verreken nie. Tekortkominge in beide Westerse en Afrika humanisme word aangetoon. Navolging van ’n dinamiese en resiprokale benadering wat beide self-gelding (individualisties) en self-transendering (kollektiwisties) in menslike natuur insluit, word voorgehou as ’n meer omvattende beskouing wat ’n beter begrip van gedrag in werkorganisasies bied. Daar is heelwat retoriek in aansprake betreffende Afrika humanisme. Verdere navorsing, veral begronde en interpreterende studies, is noodsaaklik

The Iron Cage Re‐revisited: Institutional Isomorphism in Non‐profit Organisations in South Africa

“…Vulgarised in popular South African management literature (e.g. Mbigi, 1995), Ubuntu is argued to offer an alternative discourse to the assimilation of Western managerial values of individualism and modernity (Pietersen, 2005). As Newenham-Kahindi (2009, p. 92) pointed out, 'the emphasis in Ubuntu is on group solidarity and relationshipbuilding.…”

Rethinking decent work: the value of dignity in tourism employment

“…For example, research within an African Ubuntu style of management found that "a sense of selfworth and dignity" (Browning, 2006(Browning, , p. 1331) is achieved through supporting team spirit, fairness, autonomy and empowerment, and demonstrating respect (Browning, 2006). Thus, Ubuntu, similar to dignity, "tries to capture the essence of what it means to be human" (Murithi, 2007, p. 281) and shares a concern for non-exploitative working conditions and emphasis on moral values, mutual respect and recognition (Pietersen, 2005). Thus, while differences undoubtedly exist, the concept of dignity might have sufficient universal currency to contribute to a better understanding of decent work in tourism employment.…”

Energy Justice Across Borders

“…The wellbeing of individuals is derived from 'communal imperatives' (Petersen 2006). The individual wellbeing is valued within the framework of group aspirations.…”