Safety is a prerequisite for living a fulfilling and happy life. It is also an integral component of positive and negative peace and a basic foundation of social justice. However, personal safety has been understudied in psychological literature, as has its role as an antecedent of well-being and social justice. To address this, the current study provided evidence for the association of personal safety with positive life outcomes. Analyses were conducted using data from 59 countries via the World Values Survey. After controlling for subjective socioeconomic status, significant positive associations were observed between personal safety and increased: (H1) self-flourishment, operationally defined as subjective happiness, satisfaction with life, and subjective health; (H2) perceived freedom in one’s life; (H3) perceived fairness in one’s life; (H4) active membership within a local community; and (H5) increased trust in others. An examination of the effect of victimization as a stressor of personal safety was also conducted, with personal victimization (H6), and the victimization of a family member (H7), both acting as stressors of personal safety in most of the countries. Replication rates among the 59 countries were higher for hypotheses H1 and H6–H7. Replication rates for hypotheses H2–H5 were also observed but toq a lower degree, with higher percentages observed in western and English-speaking countries. Personal safety is a crucial component of our society, worthy of further and more comprehensive investigations.