Ways of seeing environmental change: Participatory research engagement in Yunnan, China, with ethnic minority Hani participants

Abstract

In this article, I reflect on a participatory learning and action (PLA) and participatory geographic information system (PGIS) project undertaken in two adjacent Hani villages in southern Yunnan, China. After a lengthy process to gain research authorisations, Hani villagers worked with a group of visiting researchers (Hani, Han Chinese and New Zealanders) to articulate local visions of land-use change and environmental challenges. PLA exercises produced a diverse range of hand-made and PGIS products over a 10-week period. As villagers became more accustomed to the 'outsider team' , methods -both designed and spontaneous -diversified. Afterwards, based on the results and acting on their own initiative, local leaders backed by popular support moved quickly to reassert traditional and ritually prescribed Hani conservation measures. Nevertheless, these endogenously driven solutions were not necessarily universally beneficial. In describing the complexities encountered in implementing a participatory framework and the ambiguities of the outcomes engendered, I argue that privileging local coherence and celebrating such participatory approaches should not be done at the expense of ignoring the intricacies of on-going contradictory behaviours in a rapidly changing arena. Yet, in China, where authorities often remain suspicious of those seeking to undertake long-term fieldwork, especially among ethnic minorities, PLA offers a potential route forward. Figure 3. Historical transect of Shangshapu village 1950Shangshapu village , 1980Shangshapu village , 1999 The symbols represent different types of landforms or vegetation. As for Figure 1, the results submitted by the Hani research team are on the left and the computer generated enhanced version is on the right. Ways of seeing environmental change

Misperceptions of climate-change risk as barriers to climate-change adaptation: a case study from the Rewa Delta, Fiji

“…Other approaches to environmental issues in comparable situations have used participatory learning and action (PLA) effectively (Terry and Khatri 2009;McKinnon 2010).…”

Fragrant Frontier: Global Spice Entanglements from the Sino-Vietnamese Uplands

“…This relatively highly priced spice requires comparatively little labour or fertiliser compared to many other upland crops -important factors that explain the growing popularity of black cardamom cultivation in recent decades among ethnic minority farmers who have access to the appropriate forests. In southeast Yunnan, where cardamom was previously gathered from the forest for household use, cardamom is now a notable non-timber forest product cultivated as a cash crop (McKinnon, 2011). Similarly, in the northern upland provinces of Vietnam, residents historically used cardamom for a variety of purposes, including cooking and the treatment of ailments, both for people and for their prized water buffalo.…”