Wasting the doctor's time? A video-elicitation interview study with patients in primary care

Abstract

Reaching a decision about whether and when to visit the doctor can be a difficult process for the patient. An early visit may cause the doctor to wonder why the patient chose to consult when the disease was self-limiting and symptoms would have settled without medical input. A late visit may cause the doctor to express dismay that the patient waited so long before consulting. In the UK primary care context of constrained resources and government calls for cautious healthcare spending, there is all the more pressure on both doctor and patient to meet only when necessary. A tendency on the part of health professionals to judge patients' decisions to consult as appropriate or not is already described. What is less well explored is the patient's experience of such judgment. Drawing on data from 52 video-elicitation interviews conducted in the English primary care setting, the present paper examines how patients seek to legitimise their decision to consult, and their struggles in doing so. The concern over wasting the doctor's time is expressed repeatedly through patients' narratives. Referring to the sociological literature, the history of ‘trivia’ in defining the role of general practice is discussed, and current public discourses seeking to assist the patient in developing appropriate consulting behaviour are considered and problematised. Whilst the patient is expected to have sufficient insight to inform timely consulting behaviour, it becomes clear that any attempt on the part of doctor or patient to define legitimate help-seeking is in fact elusive. Despite this, a significant moral dimension to what is deemed appropriate consulting by doctors and patients remains. The notion of candidacy is suggested as a suitable framework and way forward for encompassing these struggles to negotiate eligibility for medical time.

Lung cancer symptom appraisal among people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A qualitative interview study

“…Moving beyond social interaction to wider cultural influences, we identified a concern among COPD participants about being labelled a “time‐waster” and valued cultural attributes of stoicism. Worry about wasting the doctor's time is a well‐recognised barrier to prompt help seeking and demonstrates the complex and delicate moral balance patients have to make between responsible use of health care services and not taking unnecessary risks with their health.…”

Characteristics of customary non‐attenders in general practice who are diagnosed with cancer: A cross‐sectional study in Denmark

“…Second, it is unknown what would encourage this group of patients to visit the GP before their behaviour could be influenced by their cancer disease. The reasons for non‐attenders to contact a GP is multifaceted and should be interpreted in the context of discourses on access to GPs, “acceptable” reasons for contacting, and how to be a “good patient” who does not waste the GP's time (Llanwarne, Newbould, Burt, Campbell, & Roland, ; Offersen, Vedsted, & Andersen, ). However, as the GPs have a pivotal position of connecting patients and health care, a proactive approach by the GP may limit the non‐attenders' reasons for not seeing the GP.…”

Not visiting the GP and the risk of cancer: what are the possible implications for research, policy and practice?

“…Firstly, what might encourage this group to visit the doctor? Patients' concerns about ‘wasting the doctor's time’ are paramount and compounded by the health care system in the UK at least . Communication to such patients encouraging them to consult may be interpreted in the context of public discourses about GPs’ time being in short supply.…”

“…Patients' concerns about 'wasting the doctor's time' are paramount and compounded by the health care system in the UK at least. 5 Communication to such patients encouraging them to consult may be interpreted in the context of public discourses about GPs' time being in short supply. Individuals that never consult may be particularly sensitive to concerns about the legitimacy of seeing the doctor especially with minor symptoms.…”