Was Weber right? The cultural capital root of socio-economic growth examined in five European countries

Abstract

Purpose -The existing theoretical and empirical research on cultural impact is rather inconsistent. The purpose of this paper is to deal with the reasons for this inconsistency by debating the adequate inclusion of the cultural factor in the growth model and the way to properly measure cultural capital (CC) for this purpose. Design/methodology/approach -The paper starts with analyzing the limitations of growth theory (in particular Paul Romer's endogenous growth model) when CC is not taken into consideration. The amelioration is suggested through involvement of the Weberian mechanism of cultural impact. The difference between Weber's mechanism and using religion as a measurement proxy for cultural attitudes is enlightened. The improvement of Weber's measurement of CC by elevating Pierre Bourdieu's approach to CC from individual to aggregate regional level is suggested. Real data from five EU countries on NUTS II level is addressed for illustrating the above reasoning. Findings -The evidence shows that the suggested by the paper measurement strategy for CC allows for treating culture indeed as a single factor both in theoretical and econometrical sense of the term factor, but without loss of information, which is otherwise inevitable if the author try to approximate culture with a single mono-dimensional variable such as religion. Originality/value -Through discussion on Rome's endogenous growth model and Weber's cultural mechanisms of impact, the amelioration of growth theory by inclusion of CC is explained, operationalized and applied on a real data example.

Can social capital explain business performance in Denmark?

“…Recent empirical work (see e.g. Tubadji, 2014;Tubadji and Nijkamp, 2014) find factor variables as stronger predictor of the cultural milieu potential than individual variables such as self-reported trust etc.…”

Exploring antecedents of social media usage in B2B: a systematic review

“…Social networks provide opportunities for both bridging and bonding social capital for seeking information (Tian, 2016). In the business context, a social network refers to the number of relationships and sharing resources (Tubadji, 2014), which allows individual achieve his expected performance (Cvtanovic et al, 2015). Knowledge absorptive capability is essential for the firms to harness the meaningful information, which springs from the customer network and the business partners (Wang and Byrd, 2017).…”

Cultural impact on regional development: application of a PLS-PM model to Greece

“…The PLS-PM final value takes into consideration a more complex number of statistical relationships and re-measurements for 'fine-tuning' the final quantification of the latent variable. Thus, PLS-PM is a superior method for operationalizing the CBD approach of a multi-dimensional measurement of culture (see Tubadji 2014).…”