Warning Messages in Crisis Communication: Risk Appraisal and Warning Compliance in Severe Weather, Violent Acts, and the COVID-19 Pandemic

Abstract

BackgroundIn crisis communication, warning messages are key to informing and galvanizing the public to prevent or mitigate damage. Therefore, this study examines how risk appraisal and individual characteristics influence the intention to comply with behavioral recommendations of a warning message regarding three hazard types: the COVID-19 pandemic, violent acts, and severe weather.MethodsA cross-sectional survey examined 403 German participants from 18 to 89 years (M = 29.24; 72% female). Participants were allocated to one of three hazard types (COVID-19 pandemic, violent acts, severe weather) and presented with warning messages that were previously issued via an official warning app. Four components of risk appraisal—perceived severity (PS), anticipated negative emotions (AE), anticipatory worry (AW), and risk perception (RP)—were assessed before and after presenting the warning message. Path models were calculated to predict the intention to comply with the warning message, controlling for age, gender, and previous hazard experience.ResultsFor the COVID-19 pandemic, higher age (β = 0.18) predicted warning compliance (R2 = 0.05). AE (β = 0.20) predicted compliance in the case of violent acts (R2 = 0.09). For severe weather, PS (β = 0.28), age (β = 0.29), and female gender (β = 0.34) lead to higher compliance (R2 = 0.27). Changes across risk appraisal components were not consistent, as some facets decreased after the receipt of a warning message.DiscussionRisk appraisal has shown a marginal yet differential influence on warning message compliance in different types of hazards. Regarding the COVID-19 pandemic, the impact of sociodemographic factors on compliance should be studied more intensively. Moreover, integrating intermediary variables, such as self-efficacy, is necessary.

From warning messages to preparedness behavior: The role of risk perception and information interaction in the Covid-19 pandemic

“…However, there is a lack of studies that empirically test the way, in which three core risk perceptions mediate the connection between warning information and behavior adoption such as social distancing and vaccination in epidemic. Only Rahn et al examined how threat appraisal and socioeconomic characteristics effect the intention to follow behavioral recommendations from warnings regarding Covid-19 outbreak under PADM [38]. As shown in 2.1, studies of information, risk perception and people's responses to epidemic have addressed some, but not all of the variables outlined by the PADM.…”

Does COVID-19 Promote Self-Service Usage among Modern Shoppers? An Exploration of Pandemic-Driven Behavioural Changes in Self-Collection Users

“…Beyond the cognitive assessments, affective components also exist in risk appraisals [29,58]. The affective appraisals address individuals' emotions associated with health risks, such as fear and anxiety, which deter individuals from performing any risky behaviours.…”

Predictors of coping behavior during the COVID‐19 pandemic: Evidence from China

“…PADM was used to identify the intentions of people to engage in preventive behaviors against the COVID-19 (Shi et al, 2021). The effects of threat appraisal and socioeconomic characteristics on the intention to follow behavioral recommendations from warnings regarding COVID-19 outbreak under PADM are investigated (Rahn et al, 2021).…”