Waltz Dancing in Patients With Chronic Heart Failure

Abstract

Background-There is evidence that aerobic exercise improves functional capacity in patients with New York Heart Association (NYHA) class II and III chronic heart failure. However, it is unknown whether dancing is safe and able to improve functional capacity in patients with chronic heart failure. Methods and Results-We prospectively studied 130 patients with stable chronic heart failure (107 men; mean age, 59Ϯ11 years) in New York Heart Association class II and III and left ventricle ejection fraction Ͻ40%. Patients were randomized to supervised aerobic exercise training at 70% of peakVO 2 3 times a week for 8 weeks (group E, nϭ44) or to a dance protocol of alternate slow (5 minutes) and fast (3 minutes) waltz lasting 21 minutes (group D, nϭ44). A group that did not undergo exercise training served as control (group C, nϭ42). On study entry and at 8 weeks, all patients underwent cardiopulmonary exercise testing on a cycle ergometer until volitional fatigue, 2D-echo with Doppler, and endothelium-dependent dilation of the brachial artery. Heart rate was 111Ϯ15 bpm during exercise training and 113Ϯ19 bpm during dancing (Pϭ0.59). PeakVO 2 , anaerobic threshold,VE/VCO 2 slope, andVO 2 /W slope were all similarly improved in both E and D groups (ϩ16% and 18%, 20% and 21%, 14% and 15%, 18% and 19%, respectively; P not significant for all comparisons; PϽ0.001 versus controls). Endothelium-dependent relaxation was also similarly improved (group E, from 2.6Ϯ1.3% to 5.2Ϯ1.5%, PϽ0.001 versus control; group D, from 2.2Ϯ1.4% to 5.0Ϯ1.5%, PϽ0.001 versus control for both E and D). The change in peakVO 2 in E and D groups was correlated with changes in peak velocity of early filling wave/peak velocity of late filling ratio (rϭϪ0.58, PϽ0.001) and endothelium-dependent dilation (rϭ0.64, PϽ0.001). Untoward events were rare in both E and D groups. Conclusions-In patients with stable chronic heart failure, waltz dancing is safe and able to improve functional capacity and endothelium-dependent dilation similar to traditional aerobic exercise training. Waltz dancing may be considered in clinical practice in combination with aerobic exercise training or as an alternative to it. (Circ Heart Fail.

Brain electrical activities of dancers and fast ball sports athletes are different

“…EEG data in professional dancers and FBSA are relatively scarce. In one study, expert dancers produced more alpha during mental imagination of creative dance than novices (Fink et al 2009), whereas there were no significant differences in the EEG during imagination of waltz dancing between the groups (Belardinelli et al 2008). In previous studies, increased alpha power was found for high-fit relative to low-fit subjects (Dustman et al 1990).…”

“…In Parkinson disease (PD), recent studies indicate that dance may be an effective alternative to traditional exercise for addressing areas of concern to individuals with PD such as gait and posture (Earhart 2009;Heiberger et al 2011). Dance therapy is not only recommended for posture and balance rehabilitation, but also as an alternative to aerobic exercise (Belardinelli et al 2008;Kattenstroth et al 2010). …”

A Study on the Effects of Argentine Tango as a Form of Partnered Dance for those with Parkinson Disease and the Healthy Elderly

“…A study of those at risk of heart failure found that the waltz was just as good as traditional aerobic exercise and that people were happier, which was demonstrated by increases in a measure of quality of life, and greater likeliness to comply with the 'exercise regime' (Belardinelli et al 2006). People will feel better if their symptoms improve, but feeling better certainly has a tendency to improve symptoms.…”

Recommendations for Implementing Tango Classes for Persons with Parkinson Disease

“…Dance has been shown to promote enjoyment and foster interest in continuing participation (Palo-Bengtsson et al 1998, Belardinelli et al 2008, Federici et al 2005.…”