Vulnerability of Fishery-Based Livelihoods to Extreme Events: Local Perceptions of Damages from Hurricane Irma and Tropical Storm Alberto in Yaguajay, Central Cuba

Abstract

Hurricanes can cause extensive long-term damage to small-scale fisheries. Yet, information is scarce on how communities are locally impacted by extreme events in the Caribbean and in other parts of the world. Focusing on an artisanal fishery in Yaguajay, Sancti Spiritus, Cuba, this article explores how artisanal fishers have perceived and responded to the different damages brought about by Hurricane Irma in September 2017 and the inundations associated with Storm Alberto in May 2018. Combining discussions and short interviews carried out pre and post-storms Irma and Alberto, this study identifies major environmental impacts and matching responses. In addition, the article sheds light on the evolution of small-scale fishing communities in Cuba and their current organization. Results show local perceptions of extensive biodiversity loss in terms of mangrove coverage, changes in salinity, and the quality of coastal environments that have affected the composition of captures and fish sizes. As a consequence of these changes, fishers are adjusting their effort and fishing intensity to match perturbations. Findings underscore the need to identify the synergistic relations that may exist between prior environmental degradation and different extreme events such as droughts, hurricanes, and excessive precipitation. The interrelation of these factors may result in compounded aggravated impacts that may unfold over longer temporal scales and not just as a one-time event. Authors conclude by stressing the importance of including the systematic study of extreme events along with local perceptions of ecological change in fishery management plans. Because fishers responses to hazards are based on their experiences and knowledge of the state of coastal and marine habitats, and especially on expectations about what constitutes normal ranges of change, KEYWORDS

Climate Change in Fisheries and Aquaculture: Analysis of the Impact Caused by Idai and Kenneth Cyclones in Mozambique

“…These factors may have created conditions for them to suffer greater damage when the storms pass. According to Ramenzoni et al (2020), the impacts of climatic events in the fisheries sector are varied, including changes in ecological conditions, acceleration of coastal zone degradation through soil entrainment, vegetation degradation. Our results agree with those reported by McConney et al (2009), who identified the effects of climate change on smallscale fisheries in the eastern Caribbean where they indicated a negative biological response from fish when ocean temperatures changed due to climate change.…”

Perceptions and Consequences of Socioenvironmental Vulnerability Due to Tropical Cyclones in Los Cabos, Mexico

“…This research included several variables and risk-perception questions to generate a socioenvironmental vulnerability index and an extended questionnaire for community perception analysis, a technique universally used [35][36][37]. Recently, researchers have pointed out that climate-change impacts are associated with social vulnerability; thus, impact assessments must also be viewed through a social lens [29,38].…”

“…In other words, inhabitants can underestimate the potential negative effects of this factor (data georeferenced in Figure 1). These georeferenced survey results and flooding hazard maps showed sensible information for prevention of losses and are especially useful as a base to build dynamic models that perform process simulation and forecast in future events, especially for sites that have suffered a loss of biodiversity, as is the case for Los Cabos because of its urban development [36,39].…”

The impacts of long-term changes in weather on small-scale fishers’ available fishing hours in Nosy Barren, Madagascar

“…An increase in extreme weather events or bad weather days, for example, has the potential to affect fishers' infrastructure, including boats and gear, disrupt fishing effort, and cause physical harm to the fishers themselves (Daw et al, 2009;Sumaila and Cheung, 2010;Sainsbury et al, 2018;Heck et al, 2021). Small-scale fishers (SSF) in particular, are highly susceptible to changes in weather and climate conditions, due to their high dependency on resources, exposure to the elements, and sensitivity to impacts (Huber and Gulledge, 2011;Onyango et al, 2012;Limuwa et al, 2018;Freduah et al, 2019;Thoya and Daw, 2019;Karlsson and Mclean, 2020;Ramenzoni et al, 2020;Turner et al, 2020). This is concerning given that over half of all fish caught in developing countries is produced by SSF and up to 95 percent of these landings are for local consumption (The World Bank, 2012).…”