“…Robbins and Schmidt (1939b, see also 1939a, 1939cRobbins, 1942) concluded that "Pyridoxine is the second growth requirement of excised tomato roots" (in addition to thiamin) in a nutrient salt-carbohydrate medium. Day (1941) and Bonner and Devirian (1939) support this conclusion, and Bonner (1940) has presented evidence that glycine is without bene-1 Received for publication September 18,194'2. ficial effect on several clones of tomato roots, but that nicotinic acid is an additional growth requirement for normal development of certain clones. Robbins andSchmidt (1939a, 1939c) found no beneficial effect from nicotinamide or nicotinic acid on one clone of tomato roots, but Robbins (1941) later demonstrated such an effect of nicotinamide on three other clones of tomato roots.…”