Visualizing Knowledge Evolution Trends and Research Hotspots of Personal Health Data Research: Bibliometric Analysis

Abstract

Background The recent surge in clinical and nonclinical health-related data has been accompanied by a concomitant increase in personal health data (PHD) research across multiple disciplines such as medicine, computer science, and management. There is now a need to synthesize the dynamic knowledge of PHD in various disciplines to spot potential research hotspots. Objective The aim of this study was to reveal the knowledge evolutionary trends in PHD and detect potential research hotspots using bibliometric analysis. Methods We collected 8281 articles published between 2009 and 2018 from the Web of Science database. The knowledge evolution analysis (KEA) framework was used to analyze the evolution of PHD research. The KEA framework is a bibliometric approach that is based on 3 knowledge networks: reference co-citation, keyword co-occurrence, and discipline co-occurrence. Results The findings show that the focus of PHD research has evolved from medicine centric to technology centric to human centric since 2009. The most active PHD knowledge cluster is developing knowledge resources and allocating scarce resources. The field of computer science, especially the topic of artificial intelligence (AI), has been the focal point of recent empirical studies on PHD. Topics related to psychology and human factors (eg, attitude, satisfaction, education) are also receiving more attention. Conclusions Our analysis shows that PHD research has the potential to provide value-based health care in the future. All stakeholders should be educated about AI technology to promote value generation through PHD. Moreover, technology developers and health care institutions should consider human factors to facilitate the effective adoption of PHD-related technology. These findings indicate opportunities for interdisciplinary cooperation in several PHD research areas: (1) AI applications for PHD; (2) regulatory issues and governance of PHD; (3) education of all stakeholders about AI technology; and (4) value-based health care including “allocative value,” “technology value,” and “personalized value.”

Mapping the Evolution and Current Trends Humanistic Pedagogic: Bibliometric Analysis

“…Akan ada presentasi pemetaan co-occurrence yang mendalam, 5 kata kunci teratas yang ditemukan dalam publikasi tentang humanisme pedagogik, peta visualisasi kepadatan kata kunci, dan kemudian tampilan garis waktu kata kunci. Bantuan tambahan untuk penelitian ilmiah dapat diperoleh melalui penggunaan kata kunci kejadian bersama, yang secara efektif dapat menunjukkan kelompok penelitian di bidang subjek tertentu (Gong et al, 2021) Melalui pemeriksaan data yang disebutkan di atas, program VOSviewer mampu menghasilkan jaringan co-occurrence istilah pedagogik humanisme (lihat Gambar 6). Kami mencari melalui semua 1.548 makalah yang berkaitan dengan topik teknik keuangan Islam dan mengumpulkan agregat 3915 kata kunci dari pencarian tersebut.…”

Mapping the Evolution and Current Trends Islamic Finance: Bibliometric Analysis

“…There will be a presentation of an immersive co-occurrence mapping, the top 5 keywords found in publications on Islamic finance, a keyword density visualization map, and then a keyword timeline view. Additional help for scientific research can be obtained through the use of co-occurrence keywords, which can effectively indicate research clusters in a given subject area (Gong et al, 2021).…”

Application of Evolutionary Artificial Intelligence. An Exploratory Literature Review

“…These data usage issues have been addressed by Sekera and Novák [35], who reviewed the possibilities of using new technologies. The use of personal health data (PHD) in the three aspects of medicine, computer science, and management has been examined by Gong et al [36]. Although their article examines how knowledge about PHD has evolved over the past 20 years, it remains relevant to the development of new safe PHD technologies.…”