Visual Quality Assessment of Historical Street Scenes: A Case Study of the First “Real” Street Established in Baghdad

Abstract

Historical street scenes materialize essential cultural and artistic values for the cities in which they are located and their citizens. However, the visual quality of historical scenes is susceptible to a number of causes that could result in their deterioration. These causes can be environmental or man-made, with either generating elements that may influence the perceived visual quality of historical scenes. Therefore, this research is to assess the visual quality of historical street scenes and identify the elements that can potentially impact them. The study adopted a photo survey approach employing a Likert Scale as the main method to assess visual quality. In addition, a heatmap analysis technique was utilized to identify the elements that impact the visual quality of historical street scenes. The results indicate respondents’ high levels of dissatisfaction with the visual quality of Baghdad’s historical street scenes. The results also showed that modern facade materials, security concrete walls, and degraded buildings’ facades are elements that had a negative impact to the overall scenic quality. On the other hand, historical religious buildings, urban greenery, and unique historical buildings are elements that have a positive impact on the visual quality of historical street scenes. This research represents an approach for evaluating the visual impact and visual quality of historical street scenes, providing a quantitative tool for future initiatives focusing on the visual quality of historical legacy scenes. This research is a starting point for both researchers in urban conservation and architectural history, and municipal offices of improving the visual quality of historic streets scenes.

Spatial Dynamics and Social Order in Traditional Towns of Saudi Arabia’s Nadji Region: The Role of Neighborhood Clustering in Urban Morphology and Decision-Making Processes

“…The impact of Islam on planning throughout history has been significant, as mosques, schools, and Sufi meeting places played pivotal roles in shaping neighborhoods [33]. The structure of the city mirrors a fusion of religious, cultural, and educational aspects, where religious establishments frequently offer communal services and serve as central gathering places for the community [47]. The city's urban surroundings is defined by its Islamic legacy, which showcases a plethora of mosques, Islamic educational institutions, and charitable organizations scattered throughout [48].…”

Spatial Form Cognition of Historical Streets in Hongcun Village through a Space Syntax Approach

“…Finally, they pointed out that modern building facades can have a negative impact. However, unique cultural and religious buildings, green plants can have a positive impact [38]. features and paving materials in three traditional streets in Malacca, emphasizing the important role of these landscape features in enhancing the aesthetics, culture and function of traditional streets in Malaysia [39].…”

The disconnection of the style of the urban scene from the historical axes: Al-Rasheed Street is a case study

“…Understanding the urban scene needs to be read in a coherent and coherent manner, which depends on the extent to which the constituent details of the buildings and facades are in harmony with the constituent parts of the overall context of the same axis, and this in turn creates cohesion or disintegration and discontinuity of the styles within the urban scene. From the turbulence or sharp contradiction within the axis or the separation of buildings from their neighbours, thus creating isolated icons within a single scene that causes a kind of discontinuity in visual images, and this is called disintegration, which indicates a disruption of the general order, visual arrangement and harmony of the urban structure in general and not on a part of its parts [7]. Buildings in general and historical buildings in particular play an important role in shaping the harmonious urban scene, which together form the urban space that carries special material, historical and cultural value, which is the integrated structure of the distinctive visual image of a place, and its strongest value is that it is part of a group of buildings of the same style.…”