Variations in regulations to control standards for training and licensing of physicians: a multi-country comparison

Abstract

Background To strengthen health systems, the shortage of physicians globally needs to be addressed. However, efforts to increase the numbers of physicians must be balanced with controls on medical education imparted and the professionalism of doctors licensed to practise medicine. Methods We conducted a multi-country comparison of mandatory regulations and voluntary guidelines to control standards for medical education, clinical training, licensing and re-licensing of doctors. We purposively selected seven case-study countries with differing health systems and income levels: Canada, China, India, Iran, Pakistan, UK and USA. Using an analytical framework to assess regulations at four sequential stages of the medical education to relicensing pathway, we extracted information from: systematically collected scientific and grey literature and online news articles, websites of regulatory bodies in study countries, and standardised input from researchers and medical professionals familiar with rules in the study countries. Results The strictest controls we identified to reduce variations in medical training, licensing and re-licensing of doctors between different medical colleges, and across different regions within a country, include: medical education delivery restricted to public sector institutions; uniform, national examinations for medical college admission and licensing; and standardised national requirements for relicensing linked to demonstration of competence. However, countries analysed used different combinations of controls, balancing the strictness of controls across the four stages. Conclusions While there is no gold standard model for medical education and practise regulation, examining the combinations of controls used in different countries enables identification of innovations and regulatory approaches to address specific contextual challenges, such as decentralisation of regulations to sub-national bodies or privatisation of medical education. Looking at the full continuum from medical education to licensing is valuable to understand how countries balance the strictness of controls at different stages. Further research is needed to understand how regulating authorities, policy-makers and medical associations can find the right balance of standardisation and context-based flexibility to produce well-rounded physicians.

An overview of health workforce education and accreditation in Africa: implications for scaling-up capacity and quality

“…For countries to achieve UHC, they need to invest in ensuring the availability of qualified, skilled, and motivated health workers [ 21 , 22 ] and this can be achieved by increasing production, retention and regulation capacities [ 9 , 18 ]. Concerted efforts should aim at increasing the numbers, distribution and production capacity in the Region to produce 3 million additional health workers by 2030 and this should be led by countries.…”

“…Recent literature has also indicated that poor adherence and enforcement of standards for professional education, licensing, and practice is widespread in the health sector [ 9 – 12 ]. This has been attributed to the global call for an increase in the production and distribution of health workers with efforts geared towards achieving this with quality and professionalism often neglected [ 10 ].…”

Which Contributes to Clinical Performance: Academic Output or Person–Environment Fit?

“…CO and satisfaction are the measurement of service quality, outcome indicators including mortality, morbidity and complication, etc. Overall, the value of health services can be represented as a function of quality, costs, and volume overall (20), see in Equation (1). Such function determines the direction of indicators, that quality and volume are positively related to performance and cost is negatively related to performance.…”

“…The controls put in place by health authorities to ensure the professionalism among licensed doctors are paramount in influencing the ultimate quality of care they provide (1). In China, licensed doctors have to pass a performance assessment in placed by the health department.…”

Role of Politics, Guilds and Pedagogy in defining Policies in Medical Education: The Pakistan Scenario

“…The health professionals in Pakistan are facing difficulties in registration with licensing bodies and training abroad with the frequent and abrupt changes happening at the level of Pakistan Medical Commission (PMC), which was previously Pakistan Medical and Dental Council (PMDC). 2 There has been pressure from accrediting bodies to change from a discipline-based to an integrated, community-oriented curriculum. Concurrently the system of education was changed from annual to semester-based and then reverted to the annual system.…”