Abstract:IMDIndex and within the UK. [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12] Applying and maintaining such standards, however, requires the collection and dissemination of high-quality data on existing best practice. The UK currently has no national data collection system to produce comprehensive population-based evidence of this kind. At present, such information can only be assembled by examining the provision and variation in care for disabled children with individual conditions where population-based data are already availa… Show more
“…Further, they are health care needs arising from CP rather than from unrelated conditions. Items were selected (by Author 2) based on extensive clinical and research experience of working with young people with CP, and taking account of needs captured in a number of research studies and an audit of medical care in the Northern region of UK (Horridge, Tennant, Balu, & Rankin, ; Jackson, Krishnaswami, & Mcpheeters, ; Nieuwenhuijsen et al, ). The chosen items covered speech , mobility , positioning , equipment , pain , epilepsy , weight , control of movement , bone or joint problems , curvature of back , and eyesight .…”
BackgroundThe transition from child to adult health care is a particular challenge for young people with cerebral palsy, who have a range of needs. The measurement of reported needs, and in particular unmet needs, is one means to assess the effectiveness of services.MethodsWe recruited 106 young people with cerebral palsy, before transfer from child services, along with their parents to a 3‐year longitudinal study. Reported needs were measured with an 11‐item questionnaire covering speech, mobility, positioning, equipment, pain, epilepsy, weight, control of movement, bone or joint problems, curvature of the back, and eyesight. Categorical principal component analysis was used to create factor scores for bivariate and regression analyses.ResultsA high level of reported needs was identified particularly for control of movement, mobility, and equipment, but these areas were generally being addressed by services. The highest areas of unmet needs were for management of pain, bone or joint problems, and speech. Analysis of unmet needs yielded two factor scores, daily living health care and medical care. Unmet needs in daily living health care were related to severity of motor impairment and to attending nonspecialist education. Unmet needs tended to increase over time but were not significantly (p > .05) related to whether the young person had transferred from child services.ConclusionsReporting of unmet needs can indicate where service development is required, and we have shown that the approach to measurement can be improved. As the number of unmet health needs at the start of transition is considerable, unmet health needs after transition cannot all be attributed to poor transitional health care. The range and continuation of needs of young people with cerebral palsy argue for close liaison between adult services and child services and creation of models of practice to improve coordination.
“…Further, they are health care needs arising from CP rather than from unrelated conditions. Items were selected (by Author 2) based on extensive clinical and research experience of working with young people with CP, and taking account of needs captured in a number of research studies and an audit of medical care in the Northern region of UK (Horridge, Tennant, Balu, & Rankin, ; Jackson, Krishnaswami, & Mcpheeters, ; Nieuwenhuijsen et al, ). The chosen items covered speech , mobility , positioning , equipment , pain , epilepsy , weight , control of movement , bone or joint problems , curvature of back , and eyesight .…”
BackgroundThe transition from child to adult health care is a particular challenge for young people with cerebral palsy, who have a range of needs. The measurement of reported needs, and in particular unmet needs, is one means to assess the effectiveness of services.MethodsWe recruited 106 young people with cerebral palsy, before transfer from child services, along with their parents to a 3‐year longitudinal study. Reported needs were measured with an 11‐item questionnaire covering speech, mobility, positioning, equipment, pain, epilepsy, weight, control of movement, bone or joint problems, curvature of the back, and eyesight. Categorical principal component analysis was used to create factor scores for bivariate and regression analyses.ResultsA high level of reported needs was identified particularly for control of movement, mobility, and equipment, but these areas were generally being addressed by services. The highest areas of unmet needs were for management of pain, bone or joint problems, and speech. Analysis of unmet needs yielded two factor scores, daily living health care and medical care. Unmet needs in daily living health care were related to severity of motor impairment and to attending nonspecialist education. Unmet needs tended to increase over time but were not significantly (p > .05) related to whether the young person had transferred from child services.ConclusionsReporting of unmet needs can indicate where service development is required, and we have shown that the approach to measurement can be improved. As the number of unmet health needs at the start of transition is considerable, unmet health needs after transition cannot all be attributed to poor transitional health care. The range and continuation of needs of young people with cerebral palsy argue for close liaison between adult services and child services and creation of models of practice to improve coordination.
“…However, a population‐based survey of clinical practice across northern England demonstrated significant variation in whether enquiries about the presence of pain had been documented in medical records. Those living in the most deprived fifth of the population were significantly less likely to have had enquiries about the presence or absence of pain documented than those who were less deprived . As well as improving communication for families, the HFWS also acts as an aide‐mémoire for clinicians, whether of many years’ experience or in training, ensuring that important areas known to affect participation and quality of life are adequately covered and addressed during consultations.…”
The HFWS was acceptable to most families surveyed, improved communication from their perspective, and ensured that the issues that mattered most to them were addressed in medical consultations. The tool has been translated into a number of other languages. Its acceptability and utility in other settings requires further study.
“…If you pause to consider the many complications that would be involved in trying to answer some of these questions you may appreciate the work that Horridge et al . report in this issue as much as I do.…”
and ethnicity on CP is entirely mediated through these factors, or whether there is in fact a direct effect of race and ethnicity on CP independent of these factors, remains to be answered. This will require careful analysis of preterm birth in order to avoid biased inferences about CP aetiology. Is the customary care and treatment provided for children with cerebral palsy (CP) in California better than that provided to such children in England? Are children with CP in Sweden more likely to receive hip surveillance than those in Australia? Is a child with severe CP and failure to thrive more likely to undergo a gastrostomy procedure in Merseyside, England than in Ontario, Canada? I've long wondered about such questions and the obvious follow-up: do any differences that might be found make any difference in terms of outcomes?I have also given considerable thought to the difficulties that would arise in trying to answer such questions. Take the gastrostomy question, for example. To get at any real meaningful differences in the proportions, one would have to control for level of disability, swallow study parameters, weight and height, and more.If you pause to consider the many complications that would be involved in trying to answer some of these questions you may appreciate the work that Horridge et al. 1 report in this issue as much as I do. These authors have compared the care provided for children with CP across 15 districts in the north of England, over time from 1995 to 2002, and by an area-based measure of socio-economic status. Focusing on four evidence-based standards of health care for CP, the authors found significant differences in provision across the 15 districts while controlling for level of disability and other important factors. Extending such comparisons to wider regions of England or to disparate settings throughout the world will be challenging. As Horridge et al. note, even the relatively small set of variables upon which they rely for the present comparison are not routinely collected throughout England. However, the study makes an important contribution to my dream of more expansive comparisons: it begins to set parameters for the kinds of data that ought to be collected and the variables that ought to be controlled for in order to make such comparisons meaningful.The study has a number of important limitations, as the authors acknowledge. Small convenience samples of data, high numbers of missing values for some variables, and no information on many potentially important functional variables make the results less robust than we might like. Nevertheless, the study takes an important and courageous step, shining a light on differences in care provision for CP within different settings, and blazing a trail for future research of this type. More ought to be done in this area, and eventually a connection with outcomes may lead to the dissemination of best practices of care for CP from many different regions and facilities.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.