Values of Economists Matter in the Art and Science of Economics

Abstract

Summary What role do personal values play in the practice of economists? By means of a survey among economists working inside and outside academia in the Netherlands, we present novel insights on their personal values, how these differ from the average citizen, and how values impact their economic views and their methodological choices. Three overarching values summarize the value structure of economists: achievement, serving the public interest, and conformity to rules. Subsequent tests are performed to see whether these values affect (1) their opinion on economic propositions and (2) their attitudes towards methodological principles in economics. For the majority of economic propositions, personal values matter. Especially the value of serving the public interest has a strong effect on their economic view. Furthermore, it seems that economists who value achievement are the ones who are more likely to embrace mainstream methodological principles: thinking predominantly in terms of efficiency, rationality, and competition, believing that economic knowledge is objective and transparently produced and in agreement with Milton Friedman's view on positive economics. Female economists are at some notable points less convinced of market solutions and have more trust in the government in serving the public interest.

Population and Climate Change: Consensus and Dissensus among Demographers

“…To conform to European privacy regulations, the survey was distributed through the office of EAPS. The response rate was 30% (220 respondents of total 737 members that were registered as of 1 May 2020), which is perhaps low compared to general population-based surveys or surveys that use incentives, but it is in line with other expert surveys (Klein and Stern 2005;May et al 2018;Van Dalen, 2019;Van Dalen and Henkens 2012). 2 Respondents did not answer every question-they were allowed to skip a question if they wanted.…”

Social determinants of citations: An empirical analysis of UK economists

“…Concerning value homophily, evidence on the relevance of proximity in terms of political orientation is more mixed, though it has been proved that sexual characteristics shape views of policy, political and social questions among European economists (May et al, 2018). van Dalen (2019) shows that economists' personal values matter in shaping the economists' methodological and theoretical premises. It would thus be not too surprising if it emerged that—beside and in addition to the impact of scientific proximity—an economist's political views mattered in her citing behaviour too.…”

Backward‐oriented economics

“…Such a publication policy requires a fundamental change in the established norms among professional economists (Merton, 1973; Fuchs et al, 1998; Blaug, 2001; Van Dalen, 2019). To change strongly internalized norms is difficult to achieve.…”